Mafiascum.net

In post 247, Uncrowned wrote:Where did RC coach me?
Page 3, starting with post 50 and continuing throughout several posts on the same page. I admit that his preachy arrogance might have me seeing things incorrectly, but a vein of coaching is there IMO. Could also just be that he thought you were too new; however, you've played together previously (your boy does his homework) so I don't think that's why he did it.

Going out tonight but will read the above interaction when I can.

In post 248, gobbledygook wrote:Chk misrepresented what I said to a strong degree. I find that very sunny. He is clinging to the misrepresentation now.

You've still yet to even attempt to explain how, if I'm wrong/misrepresenting, post 177 has any grain of thought that post 214 is laden with. I'm going to run with the assumption that this is because (a) you'd rather continue shading me while providing no other input or content whatsoever, further posturing just how fucking town you are, and (b) you because the train of thought simply isn't there.

In post 249, Amrun wrote:One of chk/gobble is scum, but not both. Clearly not svs.

Feeling good about cheekyteeky now.

I want to resolve this spat, and I’m not too fussed which way. For now I prefer

vote: chkflp

I follow his thoughts on it. However, he has seemed really blustery since replacing in and something just seems off.

What in the reverse Occam's Razor Kanye West Imma let you finish logic is this?

No but for srs. Walk me through this plz.

You agree with what I'm saying... but gut says nowei?

EBWODP:

In post 250, chkflip wrote:

In post 247, Uncrowned wrote:Where did RC coach me?

Going out tonight but will read the above interaction when I can.

Page 3, starting with post 50 and continuing throughout several posts on the same page. I admit that his preachy arrogance might have me seeing things incorrectly, but a vein of coaching is there IMO. Could also just be that he thought you were too new; however, you've played together previously (your boy does his homework) so I don't think that's why he did it.

I've never played with RC before.

I wasn't really a fan of his reactions and I thought I made that pretty clear. I initially thought it made him likely to be scum too, actually. Until I checked other games and saw it was more in line with his regular play.

@ChkFlip

I'm not sure I understand where you're pushing right now. Do you think Gobble is scum? It seems like it. If so, why aren't you voting them?

It's odd that you argue this point so hard and then don't follow through on it.

In post 252, Uncrowned wrote:I've never played with RC before.

Not that it matters, but I thought I saw more than this one.

https://forum.mafiascum.net/viewtopic.php?f=11&t=81440

In post 254, Uncrowned wrote:I'm not sure I understand where you're pushing right now. Do you think Gobble is scum? It seems like it. If so, why aren't you voting them?

It's odd that you argue this point so hard and then don't follow through on it.

Voted on post 213, explained why I waited on post 217.

Where are your reads at right now?

Speaking of votes, just realized Amrun's vote put me at L-1. I don't think she's aware of that nor do I think it's scummy. Simply observing.

Right now I like Amrun and Gobble.

I don't like BB and Lovebird.

In post 244, chkflip wrote:You're spending the post (177) stating how my interpretation of his replace out [

to protect his winrate,

therefore making the slot town in my opinion

] shouldn't be why I read you as town.

The boldest is actually what 177 means. I didn’t want it look like I was saying RC rep’d out to protect his wincon because I like RC and I know he wouldn’t take kindly to people discussing his motive for repping out, especially one that says he did to preserve his winrate. The underlined is some “implied” reasoning you’re trying to attach to 177 which couldn’t be further from the truth because in 162 I literally said it makes me more likely town.

If you want to say 162 and my later statement of conftown do not mesh that’s fine. But that’s not the argument you’re making right now and your current argument is putting words in my mouth to fit your justification to vote me post facto.

In post 226, chkflip wrote:In a matter of 37 posts you went from "I didn't say RC replacing out makes me town"

==/==

In post 241, chkflip wrote:"...I just knew I had seen him do that when he was town."

You moved the goal posts from your original argument. You originally said that I said “I didn’t say RC replacing makes me town” when I quite literally said “I had just seen him do that when he was town” which does not carry any subtext that you’re saying it does (I.e. that RC replacing out doesn’t make me town).

Moreover, I literally said that RC replacing out makes me more likely town before 177 in post 162 here:

In post 162, gobbledygook wrote:

In post 161, chkflip wrote:TUUUUUUURK.

I'm sorry you replaced into a scum slot. The cow replacing out kind of pushes that further into red territory for me ngl.

It should actually do the opposite. RC has a habit of doing this as town as far as i know. He just did the same thing in a Newbie game I was in. It’s why I jumped at the chance to take his slot. I like playing town.

So it should be pretty clear that my 177 is not whatever bastardized version you’re trying to represent it as and it is in fact me stating that I did not comment or try to insinuate that RC replaced out to protect his winrate.

@chk: I said I follow what you’re saying, not that I agree with it. I think it’s seizing on too much semantics. I’ve done that as scum before.

UNVOTE:

I don’t want to end the day this quickly.

I think the most interesting part about this game is that Chk isn’t even my strongest scumread right now.

I’m really struggling to find the townies in this game and that is sad.

Concede.

UNVOTE: gobbledygook

Lb was RC right about you lurking

In post 256, Uncrowned wrote:Right now I like Amrun and Gobble.

I don't like BB and Lovebird.

Can you expand on these reads?

Gobble when you repped in why did you read RC's iso?

Because RC is one of the best scumhunters on the site?

I'll take it.

Cheeky, what do you think of Lovebird?

I've said previously that I don't mind lynching or vigging there and they haven't exactly shown up to change that opinion. I'm hoping others become more active so we don't end up with a low info lurker lynch.

Uncrowned is one of more strong town reads

Good thing I'm not voting to please you then