Spoiler:
In post 237, GuiltyLion wrote:1 - I think 16 is a good, normal question, I don't think it speaks much about your alignment since that's an easy question to ask as scum, but it's something I appreciate being raised and pressuring mujie on.In post 219, clidd wrote:1- In post 37, you, like me and Ydrasse, made a visual error when referring to a post that was out of the context of post 25, which was 13 instead of 16. But now speaking, in fact, from post 16, what is your impression of the question inserted in it ? normal, strange or not very useful ?
2- Post 97, there is a conflict between you and SJ, precisely because of what SJ hinted in post 95, about your activity. Something I didn't really understand in this context was the need for you to insert a visual resource that supported your argument, considering that just citing a public number of your posts would be enough. Have there been any situations in past games where a scum player made a derogatory remark about you that bothered you ? if not, why didn't you act in a simpler way in relation to this, considering that you would, hypothetically, have the reason in this clash ?
3- In summary, what are your general reads ? (no order/readlist, just describe it in your words).
4- The tonalities in posts 132, 141, 142, 143, 184 indicate a certain trend in relation to the development that you, theoretically, would be giving to read on SJ based on the responses (which I imagine would be negative). Why didn't a vote take place on him ?
5- In your interactions with midway, you do not get to comment on my dialogue with him, in which I indicate that he was ignoring me in a scenario where he, normally, should be talking to me. Is there any value, in your opinion, for a deviation from the standard behavior that I was imagining that midway would adopt ? can he be doing the exact opposite that I imagine he would do in relation to my slot be interpreted as an AI thing ?
2 - I feel like y'all are acting like it takes substantial effort to take a screenshot and put it on imgur. it took me less than a minute and I wanted to do it to make the point with flair. Plus it does have the benefit of being definitive proof that I was among the most active players in the game so far.
Honestly I feel like I remember similarly being tilted when being accused of activity tells, but I did a brief self search and couldn't find great examples.
Here's a time when scum pulled that on me, I called them out and defended myself in much the same way, but was definitely more calm.
Here's another time when I was accused of low activity, but I was in a good mood and didn't take the bait here either. Note again though that I did ask pretty much the same question as I asked to SJReaver, wanting an explanation for what I was 'supposed' to be commenting on or doing that I supposedly hadn't.
also, for consideration, here's a couple times how I have respondedas scumwhen someone made a similar accusation. In this newbie game here - click me - I was more toned down and guarded, because I think good scum play is to emit naturally calm/cool vibes and not give people excuses to vote you.
here's another newbie game where I was scum - click me - and responded in a much more mellow way.
so idk, I think I was just amped up earlier, but I would note that my response in defending myself and asking for an explanation of why I was accused of being quiet/not commenting on things matches earlier times I've similarly been accused as town.
3 - I think you, Ydrasse, and Mujie are very likely town. I think SJReaver and Pearofclubs areprobablytown - no interest in voting there today but if I'm wrong on my scumreads elsewhere I could see myself being wrong on them and revisiting it later in the game. I scumread midwaybear and I don't have feelings either way on bebop or Walter, I don't think they've given anything indicative yet to work with.
4 - I've been trying to make sure I don't let frustration with SJReaver cloud my interpretation of what she's doing. I still think she misrepped me by saying I was quiet, and if she's competent scum then the bravado is a neat trick to sound townie, but at the same time I can imagine a town!SJR thinking my response was over the top and being suspicious. I also think midway bear's commentary on our clash and SJR's response to it makes her spewed town if midwaybear is mafia.
5 - I'm not sure I follow this question - I think you're asking me if I agree with you that him ignoring you might be AI? I don't know your history with midwaybear so I don't have expectations of how he should/would play, but I definitely suspect him for the angles he's taken on me vs SJR and if you feel he's vibing differently than you would expect him to as town then I encourage you to vote him with me.
I'll take a look when I finish my current analysis.
