Mafiascum.net

if you/mcat r both town and gamma is town, why would scum let Gamma give a double innocent result?

In post 2973, Gamma Emerald wrote:House basically realized I did have a point about looking at the people I wanted to target and is voting the other person as it’s kinda-sorta a guilty for him
That’s about as clear as I can make it

It can't be a guilty for me.

I'm fucking town.

In post 2973, Gamma Emerald wrote:House basically realized I did have a point about looking at the people I wanted to target and is voting the other person as it’s kinda-sorta a guilty for him
That’s about as clear as I can make it

how is it a sorta guilty

you dont even have a result?

In post 2975, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:if you/mcat r both town and gamma is town, why would scum let Gamma give a double innocent result?

Because that's not how it works?

Aligned together does not mean both of us are town.

Aligned separately DOES mean there's SCUM

That’s what I mean
You know you’re town and so me being blocked points to MCat for you

um aligned together means you are either double town or double scum

since there's already a scum result in unwnd/kazyan, it would be very unlikely you/murdercat r the other 2 scum so you're basically obviously double town?

In post 2978, House wrote:

In post 2975, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:if you/mcat r both town and gamma is town, why would scum let Gamma give a double innocent result?

Because that's not how it works?

Aligned together does not mean both of us are town.

Aligned separately DOES mean there's SCUM

Yeah, this
While I would have been confident y’all weren’t scum partners, idk how much scum knew that

I'm tempted to just vote pooky tbh.

His posts are feeling fake as hell.

lol

Like, he's trying his damnedest to avoid the me/Mcat dichotomy because it will lead to Mcat flipping red.

Do you actually believe scum would not roleblock Gamma if he was targetting 2 town players?

what exactly would mafia have done with a hypothetical roleblock if not target gamma here

In post 2986, Gorkington wrote:what exactly would mafia have done with a hypothetical roleblock if not target gamma here

Kinda surprised they didn't use it to block the outed protective and kill him, tbh.

seems a little excessive to block a protective role and shoot them

I think they mean RB TW kill gamma

Obvs wouldn't happen here because it outs a 50/50 for scum.

or are you saying kill gamma
because killing gamma seems like it would also prevent him from getting results on you and murdercat

p-edit: ya hes probably saying that

In post 2989, MegAzumarill wrote:I think they mean RB TW kill gamma

Obvs wouldn't happen here because it outs a 50/50 for scum.

So does roleblocking Gamma, AND leaves him alive to create more problems.

Its 33/33/33 for scum because there is 3 people it could be (unwd, kaz, gamma)

Killing gamma saves a day if we were going to lim them anyway

tbh I am baffled by the LLD kill because she wasn't exactly UTR
probably means there's a scum with a good amount of exp with her

In post 2993, Gamma Emerald wrote:probably means there's a scum with a good amount of exp with her

I could picture other scenarios, but they're less flattering so I'm willing to roll with that one because debate wouldn't be productive anyway.

why wouldn't debate be productive?

In post 2992, MegAzumarill wrote:Its 33/33/33 for scum because there is 3 people it could be (unwd, kaz, gamma)

Killing gamma saves a day if we were going to lim them anyway

I'd rather leave Gamma alive.

If there's actually a roleblocker, it ties their hands and allows our other PR's to do their thing.

If he stays alive until anywhere near ELo, I'd be willing to reconsider.

VoteCount 3.2

gamma emerald (he) [ 3 ]

dwlee99, kazyan, unwnd

Kazyan (they) [ 2 ]

megazumarill, gorkington

MegAzumarill (doesn't care) [ 1 ]

gamma emerald

Murdercat (he) [ 1 ]

house

Not Voting [ 4 ]

pookythemagicalbear, dannflor, murdercat, the worst

With 11 alive it takes 6 votes to be executed.

Countdown to deadline: (expired on 2021-10-20 10:30:31)

I'm not sure if House actually thinks this or if like this is scum doing an exaggerated impression of what they think town should think

probably doesn't help I'm nearly as lost as pooky

the assumption that there is ever a scenario where scum let gamma get results if they have a choice is just really weird?? when does scum ever just let an investigation go off?

now i will admit i am still weirded out by the lld kill and the worst's continued survival but I don't feel "there's a guilty on murdercat" is really the most obvious train of logic from that?

it's such a bad thought it must come from town