Mafiascum.net

Town
{Bubla, Thor (weak), Slandaar, Oversoul, AA9}

Null
{The rest}

Scum
{CrashTextDummie, Cephir, Nacho (weak), DLG, Fuzzy (weak), Om (weak)}

Also

VOTE: Cephrir

So that list is in no order then?

Well, that list sure is abysmal.

Majiffy, let's talk about massclaim.

Red Ryu - 2 (Oversoul, Om the Destroyer)
Cephrir - 1 (BeautyAndTheBeast)

Not Voting - 16 (Mac, DLG, roflcopter, EddieFenix, Thor665, Red Ryu, Syryana, Desperado, Baby Spice, Slandaar, Seanald, ActionDan, fuzzybutternut, Rondar, Amethyst Kitty, ArcAngel9)

mass claim would have been fine had it happened spontaneously. I still don't mind it, but with everyone being prepared it's lost it's surprise! value, and that's effective when scum don't have day-talk.

CTD, I believe you put forward the notion of mass-claim when you were a traitor in invitational... 14? What was your motivation in that game and why can I trust you mean what you say this game?

In post 302, fuzzybutternut wrote:So that list is in no order then?

In order of the playerlist in the OP.

In post 303, Cephrir wrote:Well, that list sure is abysmal.

So are each and every one of your posts.

In post 304, Nachomamma8 wrote:Majiffy, let's talk about massclaim.

Lets not and forget that you're even supporting such a god awful idea.

In post 307, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:Lets not and forget that you're even supporting such a god awful idea.

Why is it awful?

Because d1 massclaims in larges are scum ideas pushed by dumbtowns that don't realize they're scumpushed.

benefit =/ cost

I didn't like it in terrible mafia

The only reason it was a good idea in Terrible Music was because half the playerlist had already outted.

Brb mommy and daddy are fighting in Google chat.

In post 295, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:

In post 288, Om the Destroyer wrote:Obvious sucking up to Thor since this was a completely useless comment unrelated to rofl's that he was responding to.

rofl said that he thought that thor was blindsighted by our beauty. majiffy responded with "you must not think much of thor then".

how is that useless and unrelated

because rofl makes a valid point in that it isn't necessarily competency that drives whether a person is blinded by buddying or not

Majiffy's "oh you must not think highly of him then!" is a somewhat-subtle "yes thor is awesome go fuck yourself"

In post 295, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:

More subtle, but still there, especially with that cute little white knight motivation of "Oh you insulted Thor how DARE you! RAWRGLEBARGLE"

I think it was a valid point.

there's no valid point made by it...the hell are you agreeing with?

~

I don't think it's a bad idea to start a massclaim early, get players with good synergy to get working with each other, get a little info from PRs, catch one or two free scum, dominate.

In post 300, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:Town
{Bubla, Thor (weak), Slandaar, Oversoul, AA9}

Null
{The rest}

Scum
{CrashTextDummie, Cephir, Nacho (weak), DLG, Fuzzy (weak), Om (weak)}

reads with no basis are a GO!

~

In post 303, Cephrir wrote:Well, that list sure is abysmal.

I agree.

~

I couldn't remember the password for this account. Which means I need to talk to Mara about changing it.

___

I don't like the idea of mass claiming. I rather not at least not on Day1.

___

Heh, Nacho could be scum for giving a summary of a thread

___

Uh, DlG, when Mara gets back.. You will have an answer to 199 as we have some unsure people that we want to poke at.
Although, the first one was a joke. I'm not sure why you are taking it seriously.
___

The Mollie/Jiffy might be town. Mollie part feels town to me at the moment.

___

I'm not sure what to make of AA9 well the wagon on OS is fast and might be a QL. It's just off because I don't feel as if she's looking for scum.

AA who's your biggest scum read and your biggest town read?

___

How does OM/HD's high activity make him town? I would think scum would want to blend in and be active rather then lurk and gain attention on them. Activity isn't indicative of an alignment.

In post 313, Om the Destroyer wrote:because rofl makes a valid point in that it isn't necessarily competency that drives whether a person is blinded by buddying or not

Majiffy's "oh you must not think highly of him then!" is a somewhat-subtle "yes thor is awesome go fuck yourself"

It was more of a "Thor isn't dumb enough for that to work" comment.

In post 314, Nachomamma8 wrote:I don't think it's a bad idea to start a massclaim early, get players with good synergy to get working with each other, get a little info from PRs, catch one or two free scum, dominate.

Because "catch one or two free scum" never fucking happens.

In post 315, Om the Destroyer wrote:reads with no basis are a GO!

~

Which ones would you be interested in hearing more about?

In post 318, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:

In post 315, Om the Destroyer wrote:reads with no basis are a GO!

~

Which ones would you be interested in hearing more about?

Every.

Single.

One.

~

I realize you didn't ask me but I for one would like to hear what Slandaar and AA9 have done that makes them such shining beacons of towniness that they don't even get (weak)'s. As far as I can tell, it looks like your list is based entirely on whether or not people agree with you.

Papa don't roll that way. Don't want to be giving scumbutts like you legitimate reads to sheep reasons from.

In post 320, Cephrir wrote:I realize you didn't ask me but I for one would like to hear what Slandaar and AA9 have done that makes them such shining beacons of towniness that they don't even get (weak)'s. As far as I can tell, it looks like your list is based entirely on whether or not people agree with you.

It's largely based on whether or not people agree with me, yes. Because I am town. Ergo if you agree with me, you're likely town.

Slandaar's rather brief post including you and Fuzzy as scumreads and his strong stance against the massclaim make him town.
AA9's reaction to the Oversoul wagon makes her town.

In post 321, BeautyAndTheBeast wrote:Papa don't roll that way. Don't want to be giving scumbutts like you legitimate reads to sheep reasons from.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: BeautyAndTheBeast

Well thanks for admitting it upfront that these reads have no real basis I guess?

And no, agreeing with you is not a basis and not necessarily town motivated, and I know you're a better player than that.

~

Wow, that's a ridiculously self-centered viewpoint. By that logic anyone who suspects you is scum.

Welcome to my scumlist.