Mafiascum.net

And if both are town following your plan just puts us in MELO

Titus do you feel it's fair to burden of proficiency you?

In post 3201, Dwlee99 wrote:Titus do you feel it's fair to burden of proficiency you?

Depends on the issue but usually not.

In post 3200, Dwlee99 wrote:And if both are town following your plan just puts us in MELO

Both aren't town though.

Second, if that does put us into MELO we deserve to lose this game with the amount of lies in this game and letting them live so long.

In post 3202, Titus wrote:

In post 3201, Dwlee99 wrote:Titus do you feel it's fair to burden of proficiency you?

Depends on the issue but usually not.

The issue here is I'm pretty sure you townread both flipped scum and you were vocally scumreading Nero, me, and I can't remember if you also scumread Peta there.

Titus wrote:

In post 3200, Dwlee99 wrote:And if both are town following your plan just puts us in MELO

Both aren't town though.

Second, if that does put us into MELO we deserve to lose this game with the amount of lies in this game and letting them live so long.

It puts us in MELO assuming 4 total scum. If there are traitors or other things it could be worse than that.

Another thing is like, if I'm a cop or a gunsmith or anything investigative I check Anya last night 100% of the time. So if she is scum why is there no guilty on her?

In post 3205, Dwlee99 wrote:Another thing is like, if I'm a cop or a gunsmith or anything investigative I check Anya last night 100% of the time. So if she is scum why is there no guilty on her?

We aren't getting an investigative with this much power already out on the table.

Second, there's no inno on her either.

In post 3204, Dwlee99 wrote:The issue here is I'm pretty sure you townread both flipped scum and you were vocally scumreading Nero, me, and I can't remember if you also scumread Peta there.

I have had some games with shitty reads. See townstumps mafia.

Masons plus a vig =3 conftown.

We don't get another investigator.

We have this weird babysitter thing, masons, and a voyeur. I don't think that is too much power and doesn't explain the need for a jailkeeper on the scumteam. Especially cause voyeur hardly ever gives super useful results.

I've also played in what I've considered town-sided setups lately so maybe that's clouding things. The mini I just finished had a roaming detective (can't visit same person twice, sees if someone has killed someone), a combined hider bodyguard, a universal backup, and a 1-shot simple vigilante against two goons + complex fruit vendor.

In post 3209, Dwlee99 wrote:We have this weird babysitter thing, masons, and a voyeur. I don't think that is too much power and doesn't explain the need for a jailkeeper on the scumteam. Especially cause voyeur hardly ever gives super useful results.

Jailkeeper protects from the babysitter thing.

The voyeur not giving useful results is a hint that it's a lie.

Masons + vig = 3 conftown with a kill
Versus 3 scum with a kill

That's not balanced if town has anymore power. It's arguably not balanced as is.

The voyeur is a lie.

It isn't a vigilante though. It's gated behind your role (assuming it's a legit claim)

Honestly feel like the town power in the game I just played is stronger than double masons + this babysitter thing, and that didn't have a jailkeeper.

In post 3212, Dwlee99 wrote:It isn't a vigilante though. It's gated behind your role (assuming it's a legit claim)

It's still a 3rd conftown and it provides at least one kill.

In post 3214, Titus wrote:

In post 3212, Dwlee99 wrote:It isn't a vigilante though. It's gated behind your role (assuming it's a legit claim)

It's still a 3rd conftown and it provides at least one kill.

Don't agree on conftown given people thought it was evil at first.

I'll switch my vote to StD if need be, this post is mainly a prod dodge.

That

In post 3215, Dwlee99 wrote:

In post 3214, Titus wrote:

In post 3212, Dwlee99 wrote:It isn't a vigilante though. It's gated behind your role (assuming it's a legit claim)

It's still a 3rd conftown and it provides at least one kill.

Don't agree on conftown given people thought it was evil at first.

Vigs can only be attached to town. Thus conftown.

Mainly it technically can't prove itself until he or I die but it still is a conftown.

Not being able to prove itself = not conftown imo.

Masons can't prove themselves until they flip either. Still conftown.

The problem I’m having is that this game just has way too many posts. And a large part of the game is really dense.

I’ve tried reading carefully over multiple days, and through Day 1 and through some of Day 2, I have this:

Town
{Dunnstral [Vanilla Town], Nero Cain [Vanilla Town], petapan/cyrus [Vengeful Combined Vigilante Babysitter]}
Strong Lean Town
{ssbm_Kyouko, VFP}
Lean Town
{Dwlee99, T3, Derek12/ChaosOmega [Vanilla Town Claim], Rathe [ItalianoVD]}
Slight Lean Town
{Save The Dragons, Anya}
Neutral / Could Swing Either Direction
{ }
Slight Lean Scum
{Titus [Babysitter Enabler Claim], DGB, Dragon of the West}
Lean Scum
{ }
Scum
{osuka [Mafia Goon], nomnomnom / Vaxkiller [Mafia Informed Compulsive Jailkeeper]}

I think DGB needs to be hard ignored regardless. And I don’t understand the impulse to consolidate on STD here.