Posted: Fri Oct 07, 2005 9:50 am
oops.... wow... I guess three of my last four posts are pointless then...
Sorry about that. That was in fact what I was looking / waiting for.
Sorry about that, my error.
https://forum.mafiascum-staging.net/
This posible team of 3 is looking unlikely to me, mainly because of what happened on night 2. On the above table we seem to start with night 0 and move to day 1? I'm calling these night 1 and day 1 in this post, as per the mod's opening posts and I hope this will not confuse anyone.Nightfall wrote:I just thought of this while adding to the chart, but when looking at the chart (Alone) it's looking a bit like MOS, Gnome, and Mepmuff, could be a possible 3 man team.
I disagree. PBuG mentioned to mepmuff that the nightscene had nothing to do with his investigation. That doesn't sound like the explicit rebuttal of a claim that everyone could immediately see, especially when re-reading the thread some months later. As for not immediately doing so myself, I was so concerned that people might unwittingly pass their items en-mass to confirmed innocents that I posted, even though I had only about 4 minutes to make the post. The first time I had available to make a more detailed post was the very next day when I did was the first to explicitly say that mepmuff's claim was unfounded.Thok wrote:Sineish-actually PBug was the first person to explain why the claim was wrong, in 49.
Um, we know that MGIA is scum, and we have almost no evidence of multiple scum parties.Sineish wrote:This doesn't rule out MoS and mepmuff being scum together, but I think the chance for MGIA being part of their team is pretty low.
Mastermind of Sin wrote:On a similar note, the mod HAS pmed me and clarified that it was meant that Thok didn't send any OTHER items, because the mod thought it evident that I had gotten the loudspeaker from Thok. So, it was simply a mixup between the mod and I.
....Nightfall wrote:So... if I am taking Aelyn's comments correctly, would that mean that if the wrong results were pm'd to MOS, then MOS should now have recieved the correct results pm? If that is true, MOS, have you recieved an additional pm?
first of all, I've had to lurk in almost every game I'm in, so don't try to pin that on me, bud. I've made an effort to be more active lately, but I'm also close to failing 3 classes, so I'm a little busy. As for the mistake, how could I know there was a mistake from the mod when I thought Thok was scum? Since using the mailman's hat to watch where people send items is a way to find scum by seeing if they lie about it, I assumed I had caught Thok in a lie. How would I know that the mod made a mistake? And I DID check with the mod as soon as I considered it a real possibility, btw.Changling bob wrote:Post by post analysis of MoS:
Clarification of possible role ability, random vote.Usually, the mayor has two votes and/or a daykill.
vote: nightfall for stealing my intended random vote on mepmuff Sad
i will be out of town the next few days.lol, I'm back finally, but I have nothing to addOut of town posts, plus day two first-day-item claim.I had a mailman's hat, btw.
out of town until tuesday night at the earliest
damnit, I'm sorry for not posting. I'll try to catch up. unvote if I had a vote.This at a time when feelings were right up against thesp.vote: thesp
Fillermmmm, I love video games
*wanders off*
Second-day-item-claimMastermind of Sin wrote:ummm, I didn't have an item last night.
Code: Select all
Item Night 1 Night 2 ------------------------------------------------ Cell Phone Thesp Commodore Amazing GameBoy Sineish _Obelix_ Nothing Nightfall Nightfall/MoS Mailman's Hat MoS mepmuff Next to claim: Thok
Wrong clarification of item held by another player. Last thing posted before today's jump on Thok.STD didn't have the police radio night 1, because I used my mailman's hat to watch him, and he passed his item to Thok.
FoS: MoS
Quite the lurker, aren't you? I admit freely that I haven't been the most prolific of players, but you've posted no content, and just tried to get someone lynched on a mistake by the mod. Admittedly you weren't aware of the mistake, but you could've checked as soon as you realised it may have been, rather than the nice big 6-in-a-row above .
Care to explain yourself?
what's this supposed to mean? Are you saying that the mod was mistaken when my result showed that STD's item was passed to Thok?Changling Bob wrote:Wrong clarification of item held by another player.
Interesting-that supports some of what I've been thinking.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Also, as for yesterday, there is a specific reason why I didn't post a lot, in addition to me being busy.
Sorry about that. You had already answered my question, I just hadn't seen it.Mastermind of Sin wrote:Mastermind of Sin wrote:On a similar note, the mod HAS pmed me and clarified that it was meant that Thok didn't send any OTHER items, because the mod thought it evident that I had gotten the loudspeaker from Thok. So, it was simply a mixup between the mod and I.....Nightfall wrote:So... if I am taking Aelyn's comments correctly, would that mean that if the wrong results were pm'd to MOS, then MOS should now have recieved the correct results pm? If that is true, MOS, have you recieved an additional pm?
That includes me please. The way Thok phrased his vote leads me to believe it may be to do with my night 1 item. As for CA's reason, I've no idea.Changling bob wrote:Also, how about someone explains why we're now jumping on Sineish for the slower among us?
Can those who actually had the item shed their light on this?It seems to me that the GBA is some sort of a distraction item of some sort (post restriction?), which makes it a useful tool for scum.
We've been assuming this entire game that it was to the advantage to scum to hold on to all the items. But if it isn't, for some reason, then this whole post of his just doesn't make any sense. I don't understand why he would have posted this (especially the last sentence), knowing what he knew. It's very misleading.Day One, after passing the GBA, Sineish wrote:Right, so we have six items claimed, plus a possible item which StD may have had. I would say that six items is probably right, as that way a three person mafia could hoard them all for themselves. The question then arises, which of these items would the mafia most likely start with? I am of the opinion that they can't have started with any items as it would be too easy to hoard them, although we shouldn't rule out the possibility completely.
Following up on what I understand of the GBA and CA's quote, I don't quite believe Sineish has no idea about Thok's theory.but have no idea about his theory.
So you did. My bad. I was just too lazy to check.Commodore Amazing wrote:@Changling bob - I have come into this thread today to do things other than vote.