Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Nobody Special]

Personally I think he's retreated to his QT for help.

You seem to be assuming that scum have daytalk. Which is not really standard.

This only supports my vote.

Die, scum.

[Zoidberg]

Personally I think he's retreated to his QT for help.

You seem to be assuming that scum have daytalk. Which is not really standard.

This only supports my vote.

Die, scum.

I only have played in one other large theme, which was Gay Mafia 2. Scum had daytalk in that game, that's all I have to go on.

[Zoidberg]

The whole roflcopter wagon is uninspired and bad, imo.

You should sheep it for great justice.

Unless you're saying rofl reads town to you?

[Metal Sonic]

All right let's re-cap the oh-so-scummy wagon that's building on me.

-Metal Sonic goes "I wonder what the scum flavour is"
-Zoidberg speculates idly
-Roflcopter comes out of nowhere pushing a zoidberg lynch
-Roflcopter repeatedly dodges questions related to his reasoning from multiple players

To wit:

there is no scum in this game, only calvin

boy i wonder what the scum role flavor is? those zog? that old teacher whose name I forgot? exciting !

Total speculation, but it's probably Rosalyn, Susie Derkins, Moe, Miss Wormwood, and some others. Maybe Calvin's Mom's "evil" alter-ego aka the Evil Mom-Lady.

Not that the rolenames matter unless we have a role-cop.

we are lynching zoidberg today

vote: zoidberg

The question is: Why? He's not stated any case, and there must be a reason.

Answer: Well, I must have correctly guessed one or more of the scum's role names. He probably thinks he can spin it as "Zoidberg knows too much about the setup" aka I must have inside knowledge because I'm scum and so I've scumslipped. Of course, he can't prove that without revealing that he also has inside knowledge.

Here's the thing, though:

That list of roles would occur pretty obviously to anyone who's even remotely familiar with the source material.

Who are Calvin's primary antagonists in any of the comics? Rosalyn the babysitter who makes him go to bed. Moe the bully who steals his truck. Susie Derkins always tattling on him and giving him cooties. Evil Mom-Lady making him eat his vegetables and whatever. It's the most obvious way for the setup to go.

But roflcopter, being scum, already knows what the scum rolenames are and so he can't put himself in town's point of view. I.e. he can't see the clear line of thought that town would have when guessing what scum rolenames are.

UNVOTE:
VOTE: Roflcopter

Case looks genuine, even if its 100% speculation and 10% evidence to back it up and can be quite contrived


but i'll put my vote where the scum is

VOTE: varsoon

he claimed scum

this guy doesnt lie

[Zed17]

Not particularly, no.

Unvote, Vote: Varsoon

[TiphaineDeath]

Right, I think my logic was Zed's first post fails to comment on largest forming wagon and instead tries to start up a counter wagon on a traditionally easy player to lynch under questionable logic.

[Metal Sonic]

yes that is suspect

but varsoon claimed scum and he is probably not lying

[penguin_alien]

Eh, I don't mind seeing if roflcopter can produce some more useful arguments under pressure.

VOTE: roflcopter

[TheIrishPope]

Guys
Seriously
Why would roflcopter be scum
Varsoon is scum
HE FUCKING SAID HE WAS SCUM
And he's active lurking
He's posting elsewhere but not here
Like, seriously guys

[Metal Sonic]

^

[MonkeyMan576]

Vote Count 1.4 - June 18, 2013 - With 21 Alive, it requires 11 to lynch - Day 1 ends on June 28th at 12PM Eastern US Time

roflcopter(5) - Zoidberg, Dante, psyche, Skullduggery, penguin_alien

(L-6)

Zoidberg(5) - roflcopter, TiphaineDeath, Nobody Special, Varsoon, Desperado

(L-6)

TheIrishPope(3) - EddieFenix, Mr E Roll, BROseidon

(L-8)

Varsoon - The Irish Pope
EddieFenix - boxxy
Psyche - T S O
TiphaineDeath - Rubicon
Desperado - Radioactive Wolf
Varsoon - Metal Sonic, Zed17
Not Voting(1): Who

[TheIrishPope]

MonkeyMan, the Varsoon votes should be merged

Varsoon - The Irish Pope
Varsoon - Metal Sonic, Zed17

[Metal Sonic]

^

[Psyche]

Guys
Seriously
Why would roflcopter be scum
Varsoon is scum
HE FUCKING SAID HE WAS SCUM
And he's active lurking
He's posting elsewhere but not here
Like, seriously guys

Let me finish my study first.

[T S O]

...where did Varsoon say he was scum?

[TheIrishPope]

A Town player wouldn't do that because they will be caught up in scumhunting, not their image to everyone.
T S O, nuh-uh. My scum meta doesn't involve VI-ness.

But I'm not a town player, I'm Varsoon. Meta me, since you seem to talk about/rely on it and you'll figure it out.

But yeah, you caught me, I'm scum.

Pfft, you think self meta's going to help you?
Yeah, we caught him.
Varsoon, who are your partners?

TheIrishPope.

Do you happen to be blind

[T S O]

#235 is in no way related to that, it's just because he said you.

I actually think Varsoon's posts earlier were worse than a sarcastic tell. AtE really doesn't necessarily involve being scum.

[T S O]

yes that is suspect

but varsoon claimed scum and he is probably not lying

Yeah I'm picking on you but Varsoon being sarcastic about suspicion on him is ...not the same as him "claiming" scum.

Opinion of Varsoon's earlier posts in 4 or more lines, MS?

[TheIrishPope]

So you're saying scum doesn't use sarcasm? Because he used sarcasm, he is Town?
lolwat

[Psyche]

uh
he's saying that a player using sarcasm in no way implies that the player is scum

[TiphaineDeath]

^

[TiphaineDeath]

Also, NS, while I appreciate your zeal daytalk is becoming more and more standard. zoid is still scum but don't use that as a false strike against him, it just gives him more ways to fight back.

[TheIrishPope]

Zoid is scum, of course, I mean like seriously, how would he know scum have daytalk
TD are you scum

[T S O]

You're jumping on people and giving absolutes about them being scum again ....*sigh*.

[TiphaineDeath]

No, I'd return the question Irish, except I already know you are.

TSO might be scum but only if we are in multiball, and if so he's not scum with TIP.

Zoidberg/TSO/X

TIP/Zed/X

hmmmm.