Posted: Mon Aug 24, 2020 8:46 am
Can you find a game where you did it as town?In post 4649, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:can you find a game where I do this as scum? what the hell does this puppy dude have to do with me?
Can you find a game where you did it as town?In post 4649, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:can you find a game where I do this as scum? what the hell does this puppy dude have to do with me?
the negation of I wouldn't do this as scum is to find a game where I did it as scum.In post 4650, Something_Smart wrote:Can you find a game where you did it as town?In post 4649, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:can you find a game where I do this as scum? what the hell does this puppy dude have to do with me?
you not doing it as scum (which, is anyone gonna go through all your past games?) doesn't definitely mean you wouldn't soIn post 4651, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:the negation of I wouldn't do this as scum is to find a game where I did it as scum.
Whether I have done this as town before has no bearing on this and you know it.
no, that is the negation of "you DIDN'T do it as scum." It is impossible to prove that you WOULDN'T do it.In post 4651, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:the negation of I wouldn't do this as scum is to find a game where I did it as scum.
i'm just saying that this is false, it's a scum strategy that can work (and has worked before), and saying "i wouldn't offer myself as the lynch as scum" is a very weak argumentIn post 4645, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:It is suicidally stupid to make these posts if I am scum
In post 1541, CantHateAPuppy wrote:if u think i'm scum with knight, then why lynch prana today? 1 before lylo is supposed to be about resolving ambiguities. i would rather the rest of the town pick between me/una than go into tomorrow on a 50-50
This is not saying - lynch me get Una tommorrow. This is saying lets do a 1v1 between me and una today - which doesnt happen cuz 3 votes are already on prana and the town isn't gonnna move off.In post 1541, CantHateAPuppy wrote:if u think i'm scum with knight, then why lynch prana today? 1 before lylo is supposed to be about resolving ambiguities. i would rather the rest of the town pick between me/una than go into tomorrow on a 50-50
past actions have a indication on future actions. That's a reason why judges when sentencing criminals usually look at past record etc to determine whether they will do further crimes in the future.In post 4655, Something_Smart wrote:no, that is the negation of "you DIDN'T do it as scum." It is impossible to prove that you WOULDN'T do it.In post 4651, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:the negation of I wouldn't do this as scum is to find a game where I did it as scum.
well, this was the votecount, i wasn't gonna move my vote anyway, and this was the nextIn post 3575, Micc wrote:
the only person to move was dsjstr, and like anyone was gonna listen to him at that point. the next VC was the day two's final VC. i'd argue it was fairly unlikely people were gonna take you up on your offer.In post 3670, Micc wrote:
The best single clue maybe, but not the only one, and I would assume that your meta would reveal that you are capable of a playing in a variety of ways and using WIFOM to your advantage. Especially if you have never done what you did here as either alignment, then the proper conclusion to draw is that a situation where something like this would be appropriate is simply rare, and you were never in such a situation before. In that case, the fact that you have never done it as scum is of no consequence.In post 4668, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:My point is that my game meta history is the best clue you are going to get about whether I am capable of these actions you are accusing me of doing badly.
Oh also, this is silly. The probability of you doing it as town + the probability of you doing it as scum = the total probability of you doing it. In this game that latter quantity is constant. So the greater the probability of you doing it as town, the lower the probability of you doing it as scum, and vice versa.In post 4668, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:You have tried to twist that by going for the inverse of the action which has no bearing on the probability of me doing this as scum.
(1) in that gamestate puppy would always lose that 1v1 so it's basically the same thing and (2) what's the meaningful difference if your point is that "there was 3 votes on prana already, town wasn't gonna move"In post 4666, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:This is not saying - lynch me get Una tommorrow. This is saying lets do a 1v1 between me and una today - which doesnt happen cuz 3 votes are already on prana and the town isn't gonnna move off.In post 1541, CantHateAPuppy wrote:if u think i'm scum with knight, then why lynch prana today? 1 before lylo is supposed to be about resolving ambiguities. i would rather the rest of the town pick between me/una than go into tomorrow on a 50-50
In post 3435, PookyTheMagicalBear wrote:i think theres a decent chance you are deathtunneled town in this game so if we make it to lylo together the scum will win. its better for me to exit today and get rid of this distraction. good luck dats
In post 4672, Datisi wrote:(1) in that gamestate puppy would always lose that 1v1 so it's basically the same thing and (2) what's the meaningful difference if your point is that "there was 3 votes on prana already, town wasn't gonna move"
is it because "well if puppy had offered to plainly lynch himself the town would've taken him up on the offer"?
actually what's the point of arguing this idk i'm here anyway