Fery question? Your townread [?] on us.. Was it based on the mala or mara part of the hydra?
~ Mala
My read is pretty mushy tbh. I think that I've mostly interacted with mara. mollie's concerns were with mala posts mostly (I think - I'm not sure I've accurately identified whose posts are whose).
other than the latter half of yesterday, and today, we've actually worked to make each post Identifiable. which posts have you been struggling with?
You've interacted mostly with Mala
I was talking about several weeks ago when mollie and (I think mostly) mala were arguing, and mollie was scumreading you.
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 4:05 am
by PeregrineV
Limited Access Aug 30 (Fri) thru Monday- back in full swing Tuesday.
In post 5851, penguin_alien wrote:I really don't see PV as scum for everything that went down yesterday. HD was reading townish yesterday, but his stance on PV could have been blue scum not wanting to touch the neighborhoods. Looking at his vote history since the neighborhoods came out, the only neighbor he's voted is ThAd, who claimed a town PR.
Y'know, you never answered why you found my stance on PV townish in the first place. It'd be cool if you did.
Also I outright declared a townread on CTD (a neighbor) and a scumread on ThAd (a neighbor) so...what was I avoiding?
In post 5851, penguin_alien wrote:Bulbazak was townish yesterday, but with ThAd confirmed, I keep going back to the failed shot on him with a red scum doc. If HD is the last blue (and so the only likely source of a roleblock) he could have blocked ThAd's shot on him, hence the two different failure types ThAd claimed.
And then proceed to ask a question involving said roleblock that confirms the mislynch I want to push as town?
Sounds like a great idea.
Sorry, limited time ATM, but I think I did address the first part of this yesterday: PV was very much not a scum read for me. The prevailing theory was that the likely neighborhood scum was blue and could be the last scum from his team left. While it was beneficial for scum to lynch anyone they could in the neighborhoods, since if another scum flipped anyone left would be very likely town and almost impossible to lynch, town should have been more discriminating, as mislynching from the neighborhoods means eliminating a potential conf-town to have down the line. It would have been easy for you to pile on a likely PV mislynch, but you didn't.
But last night's kills indicated that there's still blue scum in play, and so the above argument weakens a bit when you consider that if you're blue scum and so had partner-CTD left alive, you might have still been reluctant to lynch in the neighborhoods at all.
I'm not tracking the second half of that quote. Which mislynch would you have wanted to push as town?
I need to read the last couple pages; I'll catch up tonight.
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 7:43 am
by Nachomamma8
In post 5893, Amethyst Kitty wrote:I'll finish the rest of the Nacho/Ceph interaction later, but I think that, so far this points to Nacho and Ceph are a team
What are the interactions between us that make you feel this the strongest?
In post 5864, Human Destroyer wrote:And then proceed to ask a question involving said roleblock that confirms the mislynch I want to push as town?
PA picked up on something awesome that I'm going to quote again.
Nachomamma8: Human Destroyer
PeregrineV:
Bulbazak: Human Destroyer->penguin_alien
Desperado: Nachomamma8
penguin_alien:
Amethyst Kitty: Human Destroyer->Unvote->penguin_alien
ffullisade: Human Destroyer
Human Destroyer: Nachomamma8
In post 5893, Amethyst Kitty wrote:I'll finish the rest of the Nacho/Ceph interaction later, but I think that, so far this points to Nacho and Ceph are a team
What are the interactions between us that make you feel this the strongest?
It isn't a specific action, but how you treated Ceph as whole and how you talked to him.
You mostly called him town early on, though when I asked you about him you said you didn't like his responses, then you called him town again.
When you interact with him, it looks like you're reading him as scummish up to a point (the point where I stopped analyzing) but still called him town, then you called him town as fuck and your interactions after that, was light defending but nothing really worth notice given your supposedly strong town-read of him
If you're going to attempt to scum-read us, you should go the entire mile instead of stopping half-way through
What happened to your strong town-read in Penguin anyway? Mala agreed with you there so, if you are town, you maybe at least did something right!
PV's probably right, in that there's two red and one blue
You're red and HD is blue
we just need to find that other red
FFery, I said Mala had a town-read on HD and that she'll explain it if she came back, though apparently it wasn't all that strong because she waffled last night when I told her my town-read on him died a long, long time ago
I could prolly go on a paranoia run on anyone who isn't in hydra atm
Bulb, what do you think of these posts?
specifically the last one, because it has just as, if not more, potential to be construed as scummy compared to the post you chose to scum-read us off with.
If you're going to say you aren't ignoring my post, and are unable to even tell the difference between our posts, at least make the effort to scum-read everything we say as a whole and not just a select few
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 2:19 pm
by Amethyst Kitty
As a bonus, the first two quotes could also easily be construed as me "trying to look pro-town"!
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 2:24 pm
by ffullisade
In post 5912, Amethyst Kitty wrote:Ffery, why don't you think Nacho is scum? I agree with you logically, though Gut says something different
and yes, the argument between our accounts was mostly mala/mollie
I'll answer this in a day or 2. I'm mulling over some things that I think points strongly to town-Nacho.
In post 5912, Amethyst Kitty wrote:Ffery, why don't you think Nacho is scum? I agree with you logically, though Gut says something different
and yes, the argument between our accounts was mostly mala/mollie
I'll answer this in a day or 2. I'm mulling over some things that I think points strongly to town-Nacho.
K
I can wait
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 5:38 pm
by Nachomamma8
In post 5913, Amethyst Kitty wrote:When you interact with him, it looks like you're reading him as scummish up to a point (the point where I stopped analyzing) but still called him town, then you called him town as fuck and your interactions after that, was light defending but nothing really worth notice given your supposedly strong town-read of him
I am naturally paranoid of my read on Cephrir; he's more confident as scum (him and I stomp-thwomped a town together in our time), meaning that sometimes he sends out false positives as town that aren't actually him being scummy. He's also the type of player that plays scum well enough and I'm not familiar enough with yet that keeps me on my toes, meaning all town reads have dark edges. Here is a game where we were scumbuddies who ended up replacing in at the same time, compare our interactions here to our interactions there and tell me what you think.
Posted: Fri Aug 30, 2013 5:55 pm
by Amethyst Kitty
I did a quick Iso on you and you definitely talked to Ceph there as much as you have here, though there is a lot less you trying to figure him out there compared to here. If I was to compare the games side by side, and read you solely off of that, I would say that the two of you probably aren't scum together this game
Posted: Sat Aug 31, 2013 4:27 am
by ffullisade
HD, there's something I'd like to talk about when you are around. One of our mutual past games.
