Im not really one for putting reads directly out there however if I see something worth mentioning I do that instead.
If you would rather a reads list I am sure I can put one together for you
In post 609, Dunnstral wrote:I think we should take care of them and MiniMegabyte, I don't have a preference between the two
Why specifically the two of us?
Both off wagon and looking through isos, I don't see anything to point towards not being partners. Both of you have interacted minimally with Artemenia. I think it is likely that there is scum in here, and at the very least there is no reason for me to think you two are town.
And Dunn is responding. My solve is Dunn is the other Mafioso (main) and implo is the Traitor. Piece if cake.
Hmm, I like the idea but not sure this game is a piece of cake already.
From page #25 + wiki, if I understand correctly, The weak hider
hides behind
the target of their
night choice
and if the
night choice
is
scum
, then the weak hider will
die
because of
targeting scum
at the night, right? If so, then I believe it's
implosion
. At least, by seeing
PenguinPower
's gameplay on Day 1, it indicates
implosion
.
VOTE: implosion
Also, I don't understand the
Mafia Traitor
role clearly, is it a choice or they have to betray the mafia team? How this role works basically?
In post 626, implosion wrote:penguinpower "crumbing" a hide on me by scumreading me half the day then not scumreading me half the day would be absolutely hilariously bad play.
N_M makes sense as a target; open 806 just ended where Penguin incorrectly townread N_M but his play this game IMO was a bit starkly different from that one (hence me saying I lightly townread him).
In post 621, Almost50 wrote:and the way PP plays Weak Hider is NOT to try and survive, but rather as a one-shot Cop.
based on...?
PP character. He even OUTED he was the Weak Hider when he promptly responded to Artimiana's fake claim with one word: Liar (tell me you didn't notice that too)
Agreed.
In post 636, Dunnstral wrote:I disagree that penguin crumbed that he was going to hide behind implosion
In post 609, Dunnstral wrote:I think we should take care of them and MiniMegabyte, I don't have a preference between the two
Why specifically the two of us?
Both off wagon and looking through isos, I don't see anything to point towards not being partners. Both of you have interacted minimally with Artemenia. I think it is likely that there is scum in here, and at the very least there is no reason for me to think you two are town.
MiniMegabyte
is in my null list and I'm not going to advocate her here but only myself. I had minimal interactions with other players too, not only
Artemiana
. The reason behind my minimal interactions is my exams. Then I started to catch up but
Artemiana
was on V/LA, so the chance to interact with (specifically) her became less. Then the wrong hammer happened before I came online, and I'm the one who identifies that the day was not over yet. After that, I was catching up again, while
Artemiana
still didn't show up. I didn't want to over the day soon without hearing what she had to say, but there is a thing called
time difference
and for that, I couldn't be online at the time
Artemiana
decided to show up and made her case as bad as hell. If I was there that time, I also voted her.
With 7 votes, Artemiana has been eliminated. They were a
Spoiler:
Mafia Goon
[/spoiler]
Night 1 ends in (expired on 2021-03-20 00:21:14)
Who do you suspicious of most from the off-wagon?
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2021 3:48 am
by Scipio1
In post 658, Salsabil Faria wrote:I had minimal interactions with other players too, not only Artemiana. The reason behind my minimal interactions is my exams. Then I started to catch up but Artemiana was on V/LA, so the chance to interact with (specifically) her became less. Then the wrong hammer happened before I came online, and I'm the one who identifies that the day was not over yet. After that, I was catching up again, while Artemiana still didn't show up. I didn't want to over the day soon without hearing what she had to say, but there is a thing called time difference and for that, I couldn't be online at the time Artemiana decided to show up and made her case as bad as hell. If I was there that time, I also voted her.
In post 658, Salsabil Faria wrote:I had minimal interactions with other players too, not only Artemiana. The reason behind my minimal interactions is my exams. Then I started to catch up but Artemiana was on V/LA, so the chance to interact with (specifically) her became less. Then the wrong hammer happened before I came online, and I'm the one who identifies that the day was not over yet. After that, I was catching up again, while Artemiana still didn't show up. I didn't want to over the day soon without hearing what she had to say, but there is a thing called time difference and for that, I couldn't be online at the time Artemiana decided to show up and made her case as bad as hell. If I was there that time, I also voted her.
where he uses n_m verbiage of "clodpole" from the beginning of the day to indicate where he is hiding. an astute scum may have actually figured that out...
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2021 4:56 am
by Something_Smart
In post 657, Salsabil Faria wrote:Maybe a terrible play but not 0 helpful for the town? Like, PenguinPower's targeting implosion strongly on Day 1, then his dying at N1 most probably indicates another scum (in this case implosion) here? His questionable terrible play according to you, actually not that terrible? AT Day 1, we caught 1 scum, from PenguinPower's dying we may have caught another one.... not that bad actually.
But like, if he already scumreads implosion, he could just target someone else and try to execute implosion today. Since he's a confirmed PR people would probably listen to him, and then we'd have one fewer dead townie and two alive confirmed townies.
where he uses n_m verbiage of "clodpole" from the beginning of the day to indicate where he is hiding. an astute scum may have actually figured that out...
Well, in that case they did not kill
Not_Mafia
then? By keeping him alive, they could lead to a miselimination on Day 2?
Also, if your theory is correct then
Not_Mafia
and
PenguinPower
both got night killed on the same night which means the mafia can double-nk? Is it possible in this set-up?
Posted: Mon Mar 22, 2021 5:04 am
by Scipio1
no -_-
if the hider hides behind the NK target they both die
In post 657, Salsabil Faria wrote:Maybe a terrible play but not 0 helpful for the town? Like, PenguinPower's targeting implosion strongly on Day 1, then his dying at N1 most probably indicates another scum (in this case implosion) here? His questionable terrible play according to you, actually not that terrible? AT Day 1, we caught 1 scum, from PenguinPower's dying we may have caught another one.... not that bad actually.
But like, if he already scumreads implosion, he could just target someone else and try to execute implosion today. Since he's a confirmed PR people would probably listen to him, and then we'd have one fewer dead townie and two alive confirmed townies.
But he couldn't know his scumread on
implosion
was right or wrong? He did strongly and openly scumread
implosion
, but later
Artemiana
's wagon was building up (which is also interesting cause the other wagon he insisted on from the beginning was
