Mafiascum.net

Kinetic wrote:

Battle Mage wrote:If you dont agree with me, why not explain your view. I'm lost as to why you would vote Ribwich...

I... did. I explained exactly what I don't agree with and why I wanted to skip the second group. I've been very clear there.

I didnt ask that, did i?

Kinetic wrote: And don't confuse the issue by bringing two separate arguments and trying to combine them.

I didnt. I gave 2 distinct reasons for being concerned about your play. You are the one who is confusing them.

Kinetic wrote: As for ribwich, that is another story, and I have my reasons. At this time though I'm not really up to explaining them all.

Which brings me back to my original point. If you don't agree with me, and won't explain why, you can see why i'd have a problem with you, right?

Kinetic wrote:

Battle Mage wrote:

Kinetic wrote: Obviously I'd be town if I voted for SL and DGB in your world BM. But let me ask you this: In every game you've thought I was scum (which, ironically is every game we've played in together), how many times was I scum?

I can only recall playing 1 or possibly 2 other games with you. In 1 you were a neutral survivor, and in the other i'm not sure. But we dont have an extensive list of shared games...

BM

Really? Seeing as I've never been a neutral survivor in any game I've played in, that would be very difficult.

Freaktown:
I was town (Psychiatrist with Emperor Ability)
You were town

Not sure then. Might not even have been you. Which says alot in itself lol. Did i play the entirety of Freaktown? I vaguely recall it, but nothing specific. Certainly nothing about being suspicious of you.

So you think i'm tunnel-visioning you, because, AT MOST, i suspected you in 1 game?

Not buying it.

BM

Kinetic wrote:Well I'll say this much. I'm never going to vote for someone who I don't think has a very good chance in my opinion of being town. There are just other reasons to my thinking that are influencing me toward rib rather than DoS or DGB at this moment in time.

I'm no brain-surgeon, but this doesnt explain anything to me atall. -.-

BM

Empking wrote:

qwints wrote:

Empking wrote:

Vote; Ribwich

Could you give some reason please?

DGB and DoS are scummy. Ribwich isn't.

Wrong, wrong, and...wrong. Ribwich is scummy as hell. the other 2, from what i recall, aren't. Please clarify why you are making these schoolboy errors!

BM

Don't worry BM, we have vigs for players like Empking.

pop is right; there are no roles. So Kinetic is doing what exactly?

since he's been presenting the most decent cases. I don't want to attack DrippingGoofball's humor, but I've seen very little actual content from her, and I'll consider DragonsofSummer when he's out of V/LA.

From what I recall, ribwich was pretty scummy.

iLord wrote:From what I recall, ribwich was pretty scummy.

qft. This game is beyond me...

BM

DrippingGoofball wrote:

qwints wrote:

Empking wrote:

Vote; Ribwich

Could you give some reason please?

Indeed, in what way does ribwich's play strike you as exceptionally townie? I'd liked to know, scum.

This post is ridiculously scummy. DoS hasn't posted much.

Empking wrote:This post is ridiculously scummy. DoS hasn't posted much.

How was that post indicative of scum?

Not posting much =/= scummy. Ribwich = scummy.

Remind me of the ribwich case again?

ZOMG!! Stranger Coug Is SCUM!!! He attacked DGBs play, DIE SCUM DIE!

Max wrote:ZOMG!! Stranger Coug Is SCUM!!! He attacked DGBs play, DIE SCUM DIE!

ABSOLUTELY!!! I AGREE 100% and MORE!!!

Those professing ribwich-love worry me much more than ribwich himself. These players are acting as if they know ribwich is town, which they would if they were scum. Therefore, I'll put ribwich (his alias makes be so hungry, I love ribs, I love sandwiches) in the town column, and his valiant supporters in the scum column.

DrippingGoofball wrote:

Max wrote:ZOMG!! Stranger Coug Is SCUM!!! He attacked DGBs play, DIE SCUM DIE!

ABSOLUTELY!!! I AGREE 100% and MORE!!!

Those professing ribwich-love worry me much more than ribwich himself. These players are acting as if they know ribwich is town, which they would if they were scum. Therefore, I'll put ribwich (his alias makes be so hungry, I love ribs, I love sandwiches) in the town column, and his valiant supporters in the scum column.

It's mainly content why I'm voting ribwich over you and DragonsofSummer. If I am convinced enough by ribwich's scumminess to switch, it will most likely be to you. Not before I see a case, though.

StrangerCoug wrote:It's mainly content why I'm voting ribwich over you and DragonsofSummer. If I am convinced enough by ribwich's scumminess to switch, it will most likely be to you. Not before I see a case, though.

I'm satisfied that you are expressing a townie sentiment. Of course, I'm a little hurt, but nothing that can't be cured by falling into a barrel of whiskey "accidentally."

What I said.

Actually, no. I change my mind. That's not a townie sentiment. I think I might have fallen into the whiskey prematurely - damn kids leaving banana peels on the floor and such.

It's not a townie sentiment because ribwich's performance hasn't been stellar - and yes, I do believe that it takes a scum that knows that ribwich is town to insist that he's town despite the evidence against it that the majority may see.

populartajo wrote:What I said.

The last thing about ribwich I can find you saying in your posts in isolation is that you find him town, and that was on the 8th. Apparently, something happened between now and then that I don't know about.

StrangerCoug wrote:

populartajo wrote:What I said.

The last thing about ribwich I can find you saying in your posts in isolation is that you find him town, and that was on the 8th. Apparently, something happened between now and then that I don't know about.

Maybe he read his PM and was reminded of whom his buddies are.

Maybe (I'm not going to speculate on hearsay), but keep in mind that if that's true, then he only knows two of them.

LOL. I said something in another game about DGB, almost at the same time. 6:16. She was being too funny. So I posted something like that in the other game and then came here to realize she should get an award. So what I said was refering to DGB, not ribwich.

StrangerCoug wrote:Maybe (I'm not going to speculate on hearsay), but keep in mind that if that's true, then he only knows two of them.

Ironically, it applies to you, too.

BTW how sure are you that he only knows TWO OF THEM?

@pop - I'm so glad I haven't lost the power to entertain internet crowds!

DrippingGoofball wrote:

StrangerCoug wrote:Maybe (I'm not going to speculate on hearsay), but keep in mind that if that's true, then he only knows two of them.

Ironically, it applies to you, too.

BTW how sure are you that he only knows TWO OF THEM?

@pop - I'm so glad I haven't lost the power to entertain internet crowds!

As sure as I am he is scum in the first place. It's called reading the first post.

I almost never agree with BM but ribwich is like one of the top people for being scum; how on Earth could anyone vote him?
This game is not vote the people who are typing the most words, it's vote the people who are town.

ShadowLurker wrote:I almost never agree with BM but ribwich is like one of the top people for being scum; how on Earth could anyone vote him?
This game is not vote the people who are typing the most words, it's vote the people who are town.

Two possibilities.

Either ribwich is town, and the SCUM knows this, and they're pretending to not find him scummy to get later town cred,

or

ribwich is scum, in which case I can't possibly imagine the scum having the gall to vote FOR each other, and thus ribwich's supporters are townies with defective scumdars.

Given the strength of ribwich's few suporters' conviction, I lean towards ribwich being town, and his supporters being scum. I don't think townies would be so stubborn going against the tide for someone whose alignment they don't know, and that everyone else seems to doubt. But I can see scumbags wanting to make themselves heroes defending a townie everyone else finds scummy.

@DGB: I don't think the scum know who all the scum are, so that opens up a lot of possibilities.