You should show your work before making ridiculous claims.
From what you posted in your 'short-wall', he didn't come anywhere near to pinging every scumtell in the book. It looks a hell of a lot closer to the opposite, actually.
You're more likely than not making up associative tells. Go ahead and lay them out, since you look like you're just lining up lynches for the hell of it the way you're talking now.
AKA I'm not convinced in the slightest by your case. Try again.
but then you would have to read metal's posts and I wouldn't wish that on anybody
a fresh pair of eyes would be good
we have 2 days til deadline
Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 8:54 pm
by Generic
Just found the 'foe' feature. Certainly makes the game a more pleasant read.
CDB, I wouldn't advocate lynching someone you think is town, even if he is a cancer on the game with his attitude. Every town vote counts.
I just happen to think he is scum and that's why he is projecting into me so aggressively.
Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 9:00 pm
by macmollie
cdb isn't advocating a town lynch he wants metal vigged.
pretty sure cdb has his vote on someone he thinks is scum and I am tempted to vote desp too cos desp is a strong player I think and in this game I am not seeing it and it makes me sad
Posted: Sat Jul 06, 2013 9:11 pm
by Generic
In post 842, ChannelDelibird wrote:Amrun, I think Metal Sonic's death would be a public service and I'll gladly help lynch him if none of my scumreads are getting lynched. But I'd rather he was killed at night because I don't particularly have a scumread on him.
This is what I mean. Although I must admit he never said Town read, just that he wasnt getting a scum read.
Remember people, you CAN make a positive difference to this game.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 3:32 am
by Desperado
In post 859, macmollie wrote:cdb isn't advocating a town lynch he wants metal vigged.
pretty sure cdb has his vote on someone he thinks is scum and I am tempted to vote desp too cos desp is a strong player I think and in this game I am not seeing it and it makes me sad
I asked you a question earlier, you ignored it. Here:
In post 831, Desperado wrote:Sweet. What did you think about his (Nexus') completely out of proportion self-meta defense?
What aren't you seeing?
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 4:19 am
by Amrun
In post 842, ChannelDelibird wrote:Amrun, I think Metal Sonic's death would be a public service and I'll gladly help lynch him if none of my scumreads are getting lynched. But I'd rather he was killed at night because I don't particularly have a scumread on him.
But WHY don't you have a scum read on him? I thought you did before. What happened?
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 4:44 am
by ChannelDelibird
I was mostly voting for him in the hopes that it might make him play better rather than because I had a scumread. I find him hard to read and, to be quite honest, I've outright ignored most of his more recent posts.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 5:07 am
by Generic
You missed where he scumslipped his expectation to survive the night phase then.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 5:38 am
by Amrun
In post 865, ChannelDelibird wrote:I was mostly voting for him in the hopes that it might make him play better rather than because I had a scumread. I find him hard to read and, to be quite honest, I've outright ignored most of his more recent posts.
In post 866, Generic wrote:You missed where he scumslipped his expectation to survive the night phase then.
This, actually. I pointed it out originally. Do you disagree that such a thing is more likely to come from scum? I really want to know because I think you're town and you have a way of lightbulbing theory moments for me.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 5:40 am
by ChannelDelibird
too busy revelling in sporting brilliance to read metal sonic posts right now, maybe later
but then you would have to read metal's posts and I wouldn't wish that on anybody
a fresh pair of eyes would be good
we have 2 days til deadline
two days, you say?
vote: metal
I've begun to read, then.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 3:45 pm
by tsunami
Gods that's not a scum slip, and anyone who is trying to argue that it is is probably scum, lazy, or just surface scum hunting and should do better. If you want to lynch him because you find him annoying, own up to that. It sure is a hell of a lot better than going "ooooooh look a scum slip." blech.
I'll get back to this tomorrow when I get home from work and see where my vote will be.
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 3:55 pm
by Cabd
Hi I'm back from being a dork. Stuff from me tonight
So, I thought, I'd change my strategy, take a look at the main wagons, vote the nicer looking one and go from there. However, both leading wagons look gods awful.
VOTE: Desperado
I'm not sure whether I read any post of him, but sheeping Tierce seems like a good place for now.
Yes, I'm well aware of my uselessness thus far in this game and that this isn't my usual play style (lurky yes, lazy no). I could make some promises now, but you may put up with this for a while longer until I get this thing sorted out (or it gets sorted out by itself by losing some of the more annoying players).
bullshit
Posted: Sun Jul 07, 2013 10:15 pm
by Nachomamma8
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:"Voted for fun" implies that Generic made his previous vote and unvote on Nacho as a random RVS votes. This is significant as it informs us that Generic is not very eager to scumhunt and is more content with staying in RVS which does not benefit the town.
It's not perfectly optimal, but generally human beings aren't.
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:However, this is impossible as a reaction coming from town, as town would not be happy to get wagoned Day 1. The excessive use of smiley in the post imply that Generic is indeed nervous and worried due to the wagon, and his attempt to brush it off or not to seem affected by the excessive use of "happy" smilies only seeks to prove this further. Generic is extremely nervous and anxious and his attempt to hide this suggests that he is the scum.
Town maybe would not be happy to get wagonned Day 1, but it was also page 2 so there wasn't any REAL threat of getting lynched. Some people enjoy the adrenaline rush, some people are a little crazy, you could be missing the sarcasm. Smilies aren't real scumtells either. Scum don't feel nervous and write a nervous post and then add a smiley at the end in order to make sure that things look better. Smiling in real life is a reaction we make in real life to diffuse feelings of awkwardness, which usually sends a nice tingly feeling to us because hey, it feels good when people smile at you. That tingly feeling doesn't exist so naturally at something you know is without a soul so it doesn't look as natural, BUT it's not like pressing colon + closing parenthesis is a natural reaction from someone unless they already use smilies excessively.
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:This post is scummy because Generic attempts to pass off a scumread on Apple without contributing anything in particular.
Sheeping has been flying around all over this game. Why is Generic's sheeping the worst?
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:Additionally, he goes on with an extremely redundant and easy-to-make question which goes "who are your top three suspects for mafia?" This question to the current wagon-at-hand is contentless and easy to generate. It can clearly be seen that Generic did not put any thought at all into his question to KA, which shows that Generic was posting fluff. His attempt to make it sound like a question implies that Generic is trying to appear to contribute, however in actuality his contributions are contentless.
It's easy, it's redundant, but it's damn good and I haven't seen another universal question that works when you want to give someone a chance. So it's still a perfectly valid one and it doesn't really point to scum at all.
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:implies that Generic is merely riding on the cases provided by others against KA and is blindly or purposely following their vote on what seems to be an easy mislynch.
or is just referring to Reck's additional case? I don't really know what you're talking about here.
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:This post is scummy because Generic refuses to provide his reads or opinion on "player X is town".
On this, I'm fairly confident that that he was just confused with how he was supposed to rephrase.
In post 735, Metal Sonic wrote:there is no evidence to show that Generic even read the case at all, and it could have been possible that he skimmed the wall of text and proclaimed it "very good", as it does not show any content knowledge of the said "case".
There's also no evidence to show that he skimmed the wall of text and proclaimed it very good.
But all in all, Generic's been sheeping and agreeing a shit ton more than he should be at this point so I'm interested in that.
I'll ISO him after my reread, although Dekes is scum enough to the point where I probably still won't be budging from him, but Generic might be a fine lynch for tomorrow.