[quote="Drummer"Okay. According to you, the scum group would have to be (ibaesha, mbl, ces) if I'm town. Earlier I said that your logic was painting "scum" all over you from my perspective. You disagreed. Wha...? And now you're laying it out that you're scum if I'm town?! What's with that? How can I not think you're scum based on your own argument? I can understand why you claim I'm your #1 choice...but you cannot possibly still say that it doesn't reapply directly onto you.[/quote]
I disagreed because my argument does not rely on me being pro-town. Although I guess you should think I'm scum, but not more so than Ibby or MBL.
Firstly, our mafia has a very specific flavour(see the first post), so being kinda crazy certainly isn't reason to think he's a mafia traitor of some kind. Secondly, we have seen too much pro-town power to justify the scum group being weakened in such a way. Thirdly, an insane cop is pro-town too. Psychological problems don't always point to scum.Drummer wrote:But wait. It's been brought up that perhaps there are just two scum. I certainly felt that Fritz's role was neutral, waiting to turn scum. I mean, come on, he had psychological problems, right? I guess it's quite possible that there are just two bad guys left. The scum group I was thinking of won't be so cut and paste.
You do realize Machi and Mike have also claimed to be blocked, in all likelihood by a scum rber?Drummer wrote:*shrug* Forgot about her. I don't know what to make of her. It would clear my suspicions of CES a great deal if she were a scum roleblocker. Possible, but it's one of those things that you never know about.