1237: The Orange Box - OVER

[haoala]

/confirm
Hi robocopter, hiplop and CC!

[haoala]

It was a pro-town way of getting discussion going. Robo's questions are more null to me because they were less game-centric and more random. CC's questions were an attempt to start serious discussion about the game going.

So defensive, Bub?
VOTE: Bub

1. What is your favorite animal?
2. What timezone are you in? And if not too prying, where you from?
3. Are you excited about this game?
4. If I say Tornado, whats the first thing to come to your mind?
5. Do you prefer scum, town, or third party? Also, whats your favorite role?
6. Whats your favorite Orange Box character?

1. Hamster
2. GMT+8. Antipode of Ecuador.
3. Yes.
4. Cows.
5. Town.
6. Wheatley.

1. Why do you play Mafia?
2. How do you react to people attacking you?
3. What will you be known for in this game?

1. Fun
2. Defend.
3. Generating discussion.

[haoala]

Vote: Haoala

I'll answer the questions in a sec, just wanted this vote out there because it's so obvious.

How so?

I don't see any scumminess in his phrasing. Explain please.

His last sentence reeks of cautiousness.
VOTE: numberQ

just trust me

Any reason why I should?
Also, how was Bub not being defensive? He responded to your vote with a length explanation.

[haoala]

Vote: Haoala

I'll answer the questions in a sec, just wanted this vote out there because it's so obvious.

for this post

For not providing any reasons for voting? That's town.

[haoala]

A random post on haoala after there were two serious votes on him? you even typed in caps SCUM. are you sure how the game works?

You've not completed any games on-site. Are you sure you know how the game works?

[haoala]

I asked for reasons.

[haoala]

If you think hiplop is scum why not vote him? If he flips scum -> lynch me. If he flips town -> I'm

[haoala]

If you think hiplop is scum why not vote him? If he flips scum -> lynch me. If he flips town -> I'm town.

When I flip town -> hiplop might still be scum.

[haoala]

If you think hiplop is scum why not vote him? If he flips scum -> lynch me. If he flips town -> I'm town.

lolnope.jpg

You are scummy regardless of hiplop's alignment.

I was about to say, "Captain is pretty obvtown" but then he went along with this ridiculous plan.

If you think hiplop is scum why not vote him? If he flips scum -> lynch me. If he flips town -> I'm town.

When I flip town -> hiplop might still be scum.

"Lynch hiplop and use this flowchart that says I'm town if he's town because I know he's town since I'm scum"

That was directed towards CC. He was only voting me because of what hiplop did.

Knowing that, numberQ, is your vote still justified?

DH you still haven't answered my question here.

[haoala]

Haoala just seems to be looking for any minute amount of scumminess and sucking it dry of its marrow.

So you agree that it's scummy?

For what reason? Because of the questions he asked.

DH never asked any questions.

[haoala]

@RedPanda

[haoala]

Then you must know that at the start of the game votes are less serious, and more for reaction fishing.

[haoala]

I don't think the answers to the questions are a scumtell. About the vote, don't you agree with my above post?

[haoala]

Now you're the one being condescending hiplop.

[haoala]

How about yourself for an alternate wagon? Because you're seriously crawling up my scumlist.

You think everyone is scum don't you?

[haoala]

what a stretch
so far I've called 3-4 people scummy out of the entire playerlist

My bad I forgot you voted Bub earlier.

haoala, yes, I knew you directed the flowchart at CC... but why the hell would that change anything? The fact of the matter is you said those things, not who you said them too. You're saying you can't be scum based on a town flip of hiplop. "Hey let's lynch a townie and then give a flimsy reason as to why I can't be scum because they flipped town."

CC voted me only because of hiplop's behaviour. Now, does it make more sense for him to vote hiplop or me?

[haoala]

Hello Hiraki.

@Bub, I already said it wasn't meant for the rest of you! The rest of you had other reasons for voting me, so the flowchart doesn't apply.

[haoala]

You guys started this game really badly.

How so?

[haoala]

I did some rereading and 2 people stand out.

Bub

for basically contributing nothing worthy so far.

Vote: numberQ

I agree with Hiplop. This looks like just narrating. There is no insight or opinion, it's just "oh, this what happened, and I'm not goin got give my opinions". Looks like fake scumhunting to me.

Sheeping. (Note that he hasn't done much at this point either)

No insight and no pressure. The post reeks of "hey everybody, I'm here and I'm reading the thread." Again, fake scumhunting. No honest attempt to follow up on your reads, no vote to try and gain more info and move the game forward, just nothing but useless narration that looks like an attempt to make you look like town. In my book, that's textbook fake scumhunting.

Just saying the same thing again.

Hiplop is probtown. Just is attitude and they way he carries himself is not consistent with scum.

Haola, on the other hand, is difficult for me to read. His early vote on me seems legit, and it moved discussion forward, as does his later vote on NumberQ. However, I don't like his "Lynch Hiplop Flowchart". That could just be a townie mistake, though.

Bub defending hiplop?

Yeah, I guess it does look bad, but I really don't have a strong opinion on Haola. I do think hiplop is town though, after re-reading him.

Looks to me like cautious scum who will say "I told you so" when I flip town.

hiplop

Was a RV on haoala

, i found ACTUAL SCUMMY BEHAVIOR, I lead a wagon on NumberQ. Its the way the game works.

They werent SUPER SRS!

just moderately. There is a

pretty high chance haoala is scum

, but NUMBERQ is more likely.

Self contradiction. His defence against Robo's wall also seems weak to me. I get the feeling that he's trying to brush accusations aside. hiplop is also playing exactly like how scum played in another game. CC, doesn't this remind you of 80's music mafia?

My vote goes to hiplop.
VOTE: hiplop

[haoala]

Absolutely. You think I'm doing that?

[haoala]

I'd appreciate if you could appeal to reason because I don't get you.

[haoala]

There was no wagon on bub.

[haoala]

Was Bub really a "top suspect"? I didn't see this. Maybe to you, but not to everyone.

[haoala]

Don't forget numberQ. Furthermore, remember that I first voted Bub. If my suspicion was there already, I don't think "taking the easy route" is a valid accusation.

[haoala]

Just spotted this

1. Why do you play Mafia?
2. How do you react to people attacking you?
3. What will you be known for in this game?

1) fun
2) sometimes anger, sometimes sarcasm, sometimes logic, sometimes disappear/lurk

3) IDK, i'm different in just about every game.

if you honestly think I'm scum, do a ridiculouly quick meta on me, I told you, I'm confirmed town o_o

It's quite ridiculous ahahahaha.

[haoala]

I'm not sure if Reck is town, but I do know haoala is

definitely 100% scum

and that little bit of pressure crushed him.

I'll reread you if haoala flips town but I'm sad that this game is this easy.

I find it curious that DH now thinks I might flip town in contrast to his earlier proposition.

[haoala]

Not good. I'm a town jailkeeper. I don't understand why Chronopie didn't give me a chance to claim. This is very scummy. Don't let him try and say "I didn't see the vote count".

This also means that DH isn't confirmed town like Reck likes to think.

I would lynch hiplop tomorrow.

[haoala]

Wait I'm not dead? VOTE: Chronopie for that attempted quickhammer.

Thank you DH. Apparently I've been voting myself since Post 130.

Unless the self-vote is a result of some item mechanism. Which means RedPanda did it.

I'm speculating.

[haoala]

You're right. Bye bye town.

[haoala]

one last post.
Lynch Chrono, then hiplop. Bub, numberQ and DH have my FoSes as well.