He's asking for it.
===Mini 1615: Locked in the Asylum=== GAME OVER
Forum rules
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
It seems as the Day Phase is a lot different from what I've seen, unless I'm reading the rules incorrectly.↑ Thestatusquo wrote:I'm serious. I have no idea what we're doing right now. Is this like normal day? What is drink coffee? Why would we do it? How does it fit with normal day phase? What the hell.
- Currently we're in the Morning Phase, which is a three day period that when it ends, leads to the Evening Phase or otherwise called the Coffee Phase. It's not like a normal phase, we don't lynch anyone during this phase (although hypothetical vote counts for people are provided). Scums have to send in their kill via PM during the morning phase.
- Voting Let's Drink Coffee speeds us up to the Evening Phase, which lasts forty-eight hours and does so if we get a majority of people voting Let's Drink Coffee. This is the time where we lynch someone by reaching a majority much like normal Mafia games.
Hopefully this clarifies things a little.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
It's to serve as a hypothetical vote count for who we intend to vote for in the Evening Phase (aka the one we find scummiest). Our votes for other people really don't count until we get to the Evening Phase.↑ Thestatusquo wrote:So then why are we voting in the morning phase?
That said, I am going to
Vote: Let's get some coffee!
. Scums do have the ability to kill during this phase but they can only kill if the kill is submitted via PM before the Morning Phase ends. Given that voting Let's get some coffee gets us faster into the Evening Phase, this is our chance to prevent a scum kill before we get into the Evening Phase.- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
No I did not know this. As a matter of fact, I noticed I misread the Morning Phase part right before shaddowez pointed it out. I ended up confusing the "3 days minimum" part for "3 days maximum" part and thought that the optimal plan was to get everyone to vote Let's Get Some Coffee to avoid a night kill on a townie. Turns out it was a major misreading on my part.↑ Thestatusquo wrote:↑ Super Smash Bros. Fan wrote:Titus and everyone else, I'd suggesting voting Let's Drink Some Coffee as soon as possible. If we can avoid a Night Kill on a townie, that would be really helpful.
Vote:SSBF
That's just never going to happen. 3 day minimum. The only effect would be that WE would only get a very short period of time to discuss and make a lynch happen on day one. Did you not know this and if you didn't why did you try to explain the rules to me when you did not understand them yourself?
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- No.↑ Thestatusquo wrote:So tell me, are you scum? What is optimum scum strategy given your new understanding of the rules? What is optimum town strategy? Who is your favorite pokemon? Can you tell me two things about the rule set we should be extra careful about?
- The optimum scum strategy would be to vote to get some coffee as soon as they've found a mislynch they can pursue. Scums will want to end the day with the least amount of information possible and to do this without being suspected, they will likely be calling to get coffee when they feel they could get a mislynch going. Scums are not going to expect townies to agree that their mislynch of choice is the best lynch for the day.
- Town should not be pursuing a lynch until the town has come to a conclusion on who is the most likely scum. Town's best ally is information and we need to make sure we aren't cut off from more information that could be helpful towards us winning. To have the best chance of lynching scum, town should not get coffee until they are in agreement on who is the most likely scum.
- Squirtle is my favorite because he's a bad-ass Pokémon and I absolutely love 1st gen of Pokémon (only beaten by the 2nd gen). It's too bad he got cut from Smash 3DS & Wii U thought; really wanted him to return.
- One thing we should be extremely careful about is how the day and night phase works. I made a big mistake of confusing how the morning phase works, so all of us (especially myself) need to keep in mind that the Morning Phase is a minimum of three days, not a maximum of three day. The Morning phase lasts for at least three days even if we all vote to get coffee before then and the phase does not end until we vote for coffee. The Evening or the Coffee Phase lasts for forty eight hours which is where a lynch will happen and the Night Phase lasts for forty eight hours.
We also need to be careful about methods used for scum hunting. While screen capping when players logged in (for those who show it) and the posts in the "Search user's posts" section, I realized that I had concerns over what was acceptable to screen capped. I then PM'd shos over what was acceptable to screen capped and he answered it basically like his notice here. We need to pay special attention to this rule because the last thing we want to happen is to have a townie mod-killed because they accidentally posted on-going game information.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
2) Untrod Tripod. His vote to get coffee might have been the result of being misguided (as like me, he also was incorrect in regards to how the morning phase work) but unlike others, he didn't question it, he didn't correct me on anything, he didn't even say anything other than a vote to get coffee. These don't give out good vibes. For now, I'll↑ Thestatusquo wrote:1) Ok. Good to know.
2) Which player most fits this pattern?
3) Same question
4) Major town points
5) Good. I missed the whole open QT thing and found it when going back to look over what the hell you were talking about. Good looks, b.
Town, is it in our best interests to claim whether we have "show online" allowed on our profiles? I currently do not, but I'm willing to turn it on for this game. Everyone else should too. Maybe we should just lynch anyone who doesn't turn theirs on.
unvote, Vote: Untrod Tripod
.3) I would say you because you've contributed the most to town so far.
Also, looking at the players I screen capped, I can confirm that shaddowez, LynchMePls, Guyett, Metal Sonic, and PeregrineV all had turned on when they logged in before the game began. I also turned mine on for the purpose of this game, but this was after you mentioned that we should turn our profile on.
I answered it because Thestatusquo asked me about it. I still believe that scums will try to use the opportunity to push for a lynch that hurts town the most during the Morning Phase, so I still wouldn't be surprised if they tried to convince town to go forward with a mislynch without a general consensus on who's the most likely to flip scum.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
Congratulation on the baby LMP! May he or she have a bright future.
Titus and PeregrineV, you can turn your online status on by logging off and logging back in, but make sure not to click the box that hides your online status.
Untrod Tripod, nothing to say in regards to my post on you? Also I noticed your claim where you and Konowa claimed to be neighbors; I'm not inclined to move my vote away from you and I would not be surprised if one of you or Konowa are scums.
MattP, do you still have a scum read on TSQ? If so, I'd like for you to expand upon it considering that you haven't elaborated on it at all.
---
Your next line about figuring out their strategy and using it is completely counter-intuitive to the argument you're making against me. I agree that understanding how scum are playing and deciding who is scum based on that makes complete sense, but somebody saying "this is how they should play" undermines that by them now not playing that way.[/quote]
Titus and PeregrineV, you can turn your online status on by logging off and logging back in, but make sure not to click the box that hides your online status.
Untrod Tripod, nothing to say in regards to my post on you? Also I noticed your claim where you and Konowa claimed to be neighbors; I'm not inclined to move my vote away from you and I would not be surprised if one of you or Konowa are scums.
MattP, do you still have a scum read on TSQ? If so, I'd like for you to expand upon it considering that you haven't elaborated on it at all.
---
I don't see how saying that the morning phase is basically a shortened day phase implies understanding of the day phase at the time it was said, especially when the very next post was you acknowledging shos's post.
Then why did you contradict yourself with two RVS votes and then say this:↑ Metal Sonic wrote:Well, best starting in the game though, none of that RVS garbage
A+ logistics shos!
Seems like you're trying to cover your track of contradicting yourself by saying "lol these votes don't count". Just because we can't lynch now doesn't give you a good excuse to use hypothetical votes for lulz, especially when shos is keeping a hypothetical vote count.
The first point is outdated, the second where you claimed I was still advocating a quick coffee drink at #43 is wrong. By the time I posted #43, I had already retracted my position for a short day because I was mistaken in regards to how long the Morning Phase lasted (I though it was three days maximum, not three days minimum). #43 was posted upon me understanding correctly how the Morning Phase worked rather than my misconception about the morning phase when I made my push to end the Morning Phase. I also don't see how I "fell over myself" when responding to him.↑ LimMePls wrote:Voting for coffee now is BAD. Why do you want a short day?
So you grasp this concept enough that you could immediately express it under pressure from TSQ, but you were still advocating a quick coffee drink. EXPLAIN NOW.
Also notice how he fell over himself to appease TSQ under the slightest of pressure.
I haven't had experience with him, but it sounds like it. I can't really read him at all, thought, hard to distinguish if it's just VI play or a scum tactic of sort.[quote=""In post 118, shaddowez"]Attack? I asked if he thought it was a bad idea (which he hasn't answered, BTW). Never said I thought he was scum based on it, or did anything that would qualify as an "attack"
Your next line about figuring out their strategy and using it is completely counter-intuitive to the argument you're making against me. I agree that understanding how scum are playing and deciding who is scum based on that makes complete sense, but somebody saying "this is how they should play" undermines that by them now not playing that way.[/quote]
I all but spelt out here that I disagreed with saying what scums would consider the optimum strategy to be bad. It's like saying that scums are more likely to active lurk or use WIFOM; it doesn't change the fact that they still are more likely to do it.I answered it because Thestatusquo asked me about it.I still believe that scums will try to use the opportunity to push for a lynch that hurts town the most during the Morning Phase, so I still wouldn't be surprised if they tried to convince town to go forward with a mislynch without a general consensus on who's the most likely to flip scum.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
I didn't ask for your repentence nor was my #43 was based on not admitting misunderstanding of the morning phase.↑ Untrod Tripod wrote:"I think he also misunderstood the rules, but because he didn't meet some arbitrary level on contrition I'm going to say I'm scumreading him because ~reasons~"
great analysis bro A+ #1 you'll be a star in this league in no time
Nice job twisting my case into what it isn't though.
A lot of your ISO consist of fluff, a crappy reply to my #43 which missed the point of why I made the vote on you, scummy reaction to MattP's post, and hostility towards others. I don't think you have the right go call others unproductive.↑ Untrod Tripod wrote:you say, having filled your ISO with activity related IIoA and baseless reads
Why are you asking TSQ for approval to move your pseudo-vote, especially when you already have UT and Metal Sonic as scum reads?
Konowa mentioned that he talked to UT in Konowa's Bluetooth thread about how the phase worked. shaddowez then called out Konowa for mentioning it, mentioning how the only form of Bluetooth communication known was the scum QT unless neighbors was involved. UT then claimed that he was neighbor with Konowa ten minutes after shaddowez called Konowa out.
I'm not sold on Konowa being town. Konowa fence-sit his read on UT and pretty much does nothing to explain his read on LMP, just basically said "Lynch him!" I'll be keeping an eye on Konowa.
Even if there are neighbors, that does not absolve you of your scummy behaviors. Neighbors have no guaranteed on your alliances and just because you might be a neighbor with Konowa doesn't mean that you're town.
Yeah I like my vote on you.↑ Untrod Tripod wrote:I'm replacing out. This playerlist combined with this mechanic is going to be like bashing my head into a brick wall. Bye.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
I'm all for Lynx full claiming. UT was my biggest scum read and all Lynx has done was affirm my scum read I currently have.
@Anatole Kuragin: Why is your vote not on UT/Lynx if you're okay with the lynch? Is thestatusquo is a better lynch and if so, why aren't you pushing his case more?
Basically, the first post was made in response to not having enough time to explain my position at the time and the second was because I thought I was clarifying how the Morning Phase worked.
@Anatole Kuragin: Why is your vote not on UT/Lynx if you're okay with the lynch? Is thestatusquo is a better lynch and if so, why aren't you pushing his case more?
And both of them considered you the scummiest player at the time this was posted. Sounds more like OMGUS because of being pressured.Metal Sonic wrote:Lmao Matt is scum with LMP
And Titus is sheeping scum like a boss gj
I made the RVS vote because I did not have time to post any content as I was leaving to go home for the night from doing homework in the library. My plan was that when I got home, I would propose a quick drink coffee because I was under the assumption that there were three days maximum to this day and that a quick drink coffee would immediately end the day, thus hopefully preventing a night kill. I was not expecting questions to come up in regards to the phases as I thought that others understood the rules based on the fact that quite a few questions were answered pre-game. TSQ posting his questions on how the rules worked surprised me, but I thought it was a good idea to answer since it seemed no one else was willing to do it in depth. When I thought that TSQ had asked all relevant questions he did have about the rules, I immediately proposed it, not recognizing that I myself was misreading how the phases worked.↑ LimMePls wrote:Lets look at this more in depth.
In post 23, you say that morning only lasts 3 days, and that the scum have to submit the kill during morning, so you think we should quick drink coffee.
Then, post 30, UT sheep's your argument and drinks coffee. In 31, you then encourage others (I'm guessing the people in game who you saw online at the time) to join you.
Then, under pressure, you supply this post:
BUT, if that were true, why did you have 2 posts on page one (one being an RVS vote) where you were not pushing for the quick drink coffee plan? In other words, if you thought we could potentially skip the morning and avoid a night kill, why did you waste time not pushing for that as hard as you could?
And then we have:
Where you seem to have a very good grasp on the idea that drinking coffee quick is bad for town. But, according to you, you'd only realized how the timing worked an hour before. So, as a TL;DR, here is how your behavior looked to me:
RVS -> Sees potential to egg on quick coffee -> advocates quick coffee -> gets called out -> immediately supplies the reasons for why drinking coffee early is bad
Given that chain of events, you look like someone who didn't want to initially push for quick coffee, but if discussion even slightly turned toward it, were eager to promote it, and then was worried about how your pushing of it would impact town's read of you. Which is a scum mindset.
Basically, the first post was made in response to not having enough time to explain my position at the time and the second was because I thought I was clarifying how the Morning Phase worked.
In hindsight, it probably was obvious that Konowa was a neighbor a #59, but at the time the thought of him being a neighbor didn't come to my mind (especially as someone who hasn't completed a game on this site in over three years) so had I been in shaddowez's position, I would have asked him about the Bluetooth communication with UT as well. There's a really small chance that Konowa and UT/Lynx may have fake claimed as neighbors, but this would be incredibly dumb scum play which I can't see them doing.It was pretty obvious Konowa was talking about a neighbor qt. You really think scum would mak a slip like that? I'm not sure why Konowa wanted to reveal he and UT had a qt though.
Just because you replace in for UT doesn't mean you are absolved of any suspicion towards you. UT occupied the same slot and he was very scummy: which doesn't go away because you come in. Your stance on LMP also wishy-washy; you claim he (not a she) will get lynched as soon as you find inconsistency with him (which in #254 you changed to "LMP is landing on my scum radar if he gets inconsistence") yet also consider him likelier to be town than me or Metal Sonic.↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:Gods be damned, please disregard everything UT posted -.-
At the moment, I'm seeing the 'authority' in LMP, meaning they're grabbing this game by the balls and leading it. Of course the goal is to 'appear town' as scum, but its still risky as scum to take that position. The minute I find inconsistency in LMP, she's getting lynched.
Right now, everyone else seems to be fair game.
I'm most happiest with a Metal Sonic or SSBF lynch at the moment, given all the back and forth, and the fact that I see LMP as likelier to be town compared to those two. Will have to reread again, and hopefully rectify the damage UT caused to this role.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:What fucking question, Thestatusquo? Do you not know how to read?
Go act tough somewhere else. What's it called? Reddit?
I'd suggest getting to it now if I were you.↑ Thestatusquo wrote:Please explain what a lunatic mastermind is.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
You're saying that you shouldn't be suspected because of UT's action, but you ignore the fact that you occupy UT's slot, which means that his scummy actions carry on to you. That is something that we are going to factor in when trying to figure out who are the scums. How is that just stating just common knowledge?↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:SSBF - Your response to #239 states nothing more than what's already common knowledge. Not sure what you were hoping for bythat.
Not once have I stated you could lynch someone alone on a whim. I was more emphasizing on how I felt you would make a major push on LMP's lynch or as you say, a "large target".I realize he was scummy, hence my playful jab in the beginning. And when I say LMP will get lynched when I find inconsistency, I'm saying that he'll be a large target. Not sure why you guys feel that taking 'will be lynched' literally to try and pin me down will accomplish anything, as I literally (as can nobody else, unless the role exists) cannot lynch someone alone on a whim.
I stated that LMP has positioned themselves as a strong player - and my conclusion to that is that it'll bite them in the ass the second they create a wave in the scum radar.
And let's look more into your #239 and #254.
You say at #239 that LMP will be lynched if he makes an inconsistency and yet said that he's more likely to be town than me or Metal Sonic. Then in #254, you say that LMP will be one of your scum radar if you find inconsistency in him, but in the next sentence, states that you think he's town. What I'm seeing here is someone who's saying "you know, he could be scum, but he could also be town" in order to avoid having to give a strong position on LMP and to be able to change when he see something they like/dislike about LMP. What's more, going from "If he's inconsistent, LMP will get lynched" to "If he's inconsistent, LMP will be on my scum radar" seems like you're softening your stance on LMP to help fan the flame that is your wagon.
And you're the one who hypothetically self-voted himself. You have no right to call me powerless when you have expressed willingness to give up the power of your voice and your vote.UT had his hypothetical vote on SSBF, and after the previous post, I'm fine keeping it there.
p.edit - You're powerless here. Go home.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
I am going to be looking over the game during the night and giving out my Top 3/4 suspicion at the beginning of Day 2. I'd advised everyone to look at Metal Sonic (currently my second strongest suspicion after Lynx) and depending on Lynx's flip; MattP (if Lynx is scum) or Konowa (if Lynx is town).
So if MattP is town, if he continues to push for your lynch, he'll be sorry? This does not read town to me.↑ Metal Sonic wrote:I don't have the time or motivation to argue with you and if you were scum you can pull a fast one on me easily,but if you're town just stay away or you'll be sorry
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
The gist of MattP's interaction with UT is this:↑ LimMePls wrote:↑ Super Smash Bros. Fan wrote:MattP (if Lynx is scum)
Explain that please.
If I had a gun, I'd put a bullet in SSBF for this post. MattP could deserve one based on Lynx flip.
MattP is very confident about UT being scum > MattP considers UT and Metal Sonic to be scum but considers Metal Sonic to be a stronger suspect > MattP considers Lynx to be a townie that's playing badly and that he's an "easy" lynch.
Should Lynx flip scum, I really do think MattP is scum partner with UT and will get my vote first thing in Day 2. I don't have time to expand upon this for the rest of the Coffee Phase, so I will be seeing you all D2.
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Super Smash Bros. Fan
-
Super Smash Bros. Fan
- Mafia Scum
- Mafia Scum
- Posts: 1746
- Joined: March 25, 2010
- Contact:
@LynchMePls: The majority of your posts today have focused on MattP and to a lesser extent, Anatole Kuragin. By comparison, you only mentioned Metal Sonic twice today; one when you voted him and another at #453. Do you feel as Metal Sonic is the scummiest person today and if not, why do you feel as sheeping Dry-fit is better for the town than pushing a lynch on MattP or Anatole Kuragin?
---
shaddowez, your case on me is awful, some of it isn't even worth responding to.
Also, we were in the RVS phase by the time I made the vote to drink coffee. Even if the morning phase was only at the max seventy-two hours, it would make very little sense for scum to send in a kill during this phase as they have no idea who would be a threat to them or who would be a good Night Kill.
- What would I as town would have gained from not answering TSQ's question? I'd rather get heat off of me so that I can focus on who is scum and to avoid having to focus most of my effort on defending myself.
VOTE: shaddowez
It's also worth noting that thestatusquo suspected shaddowez. If shaddowez is scum, I could easily see shaddowez sending in a kill for TSQ (or getting one of his scum buddies to do it) to minimize the risk of being suspected Day 2.
I still believe that Konowa could be scum. His Day 1 play gives me bad vibe (fence-sitting on his read on UT at #62, saying that he'd lynch LMP at #83 and #95 stand out) and I've said before that there's a good chance that there's scum in the neighbors. shaddowez is worse, but I do believe that Konowa shouldn't be ignored. Speaking of your post...
Two things bother me about this post. Your scum reads are focused on the two easiest targets to lynch; one has a style that clashes with others (Metal Sonic) and the other seems to be more of a mention on lack of contribution rather than behavior (Guyett); which to me resembles more of anti-town play. The mention of Konowa also reads as a potential FOS: Scumbuddy, Vote: Townie.My top scumreads are:
1. Metal Sonic: Don't like his 53, not advancing the gamestate even though hhe knows he should be able to. Doesn't seem to want to work together or cooperate with anyone. Like the wagon.
Metal Sonic wrote:I need Titus to answer my question.
I withhold my reads until I can get a good link to Titus
Seriously? You're question to Titus is just "are you scum?" How can the answer possibly have such a major impact on your reads?
2. Guyett: Doesn't seem to have any interest in having his voice heard or making an impact in the town. Those are things townies should always care about because if they give up their influence it just allows scum to take more control of the game.
I was going to put a third but I'm not sure I have one. Those two are clearly my two biggest scumreads. Maybe Titus/Konowa would be next.
---
shaddowez, your case on me is awful, some of it isn't even worth responding to.
The bolded was already explained in #25, it should not have been hard to see.↑ shaddowez wrote:This entire first set of posts revolves around SSBF not understanding the rules, yet still giving advice out about the rules. The part that bothers me about it the most is that he says in his first post that Evening Phase is where you do a normal lynch, and that it lasts 48 hours. Regardless of not understanding how the morning phase works,why would you want to limit town's time to make a lynch decision?It's also easy to say in retrospect that you wanted to limit the time for scum to put in a kill, if scum had indeed already put in a kill request.
Also, we were in the RVS phase by the time I made the vote to drink coffee. Even if the morning phase was only at the max seventy-two hours, it would make very little sense for scum to send in a kill during this phase as they have no idea who would be a threat to them or who would be a good Night Kill.
- I had already changed my stance on #37 after understanding how the coffee phase work, so my stance was not inconsistent.The beginning of the first point is completely opposite of what he did/said already, and both points are trying to take the heat off the fact that he drank coffee so early.
- What would I as town would have gained from not answering TSQ's question? I'd rather get heat off of me so that I can focus on who is scum and to avoid having to focus most of my effort on defending myself.
Because my vote for coffee and UT's vote for coffee were not similar. When I misunderstood how the coffee phase worked, I genuinely believed we could have avoided a NK'd. When UT sheeped me, it was with no explanation and I felt at the time he was doing this out of a strategy to blend in.Again, he's bringing attention to the fact that he "didn't understand how the morning phase worked". He also gives UT a hard time about not questioning how the phases worked, but SSBF didn't either until TSQ calls him out on it.
I'm willing to give a replacement a chance to play before deciding whenever or not my scum read on them sticks. There has been cases where I have changed from a scum to a townish read on a players because I saw their behavior as townie. But just like UT, LynxKuroneko played as how I would have expected a scum to be and my vote on the slot remained. Sure I was wrong at the end of the day, but I'm not going to pretend that I would have changed who I would have voted outside of hindsight.I agree that the read on a slot has to persist with replacements, but there's something to be said for playstyle and personal interactions. Unless there was some sort of conf guilty on the slot, looking at a replacement with confbias off the bat doesn't help either.
This is what he did:You yourself say hehypotheticallyself-voted. He didn't express willingness to give up anything, he was making a point....albeit it was done poorly, but that's still what it was for.
↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:What the serious fuck? That's my role. I can talk to Konowa.
Good riddance, why did I replace into this? >_<
↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:Oh, right.
Vote: LynxKuroneko
Much better. Sweet salvation!
Razors pain you, rivers are damp /
Acid stains you, drugs cause cramps /
Gun aren't lawful, nooses give /
Gas smells awful, you might as well live.
Why hypothetically self-hammer just to make a point? A hypothetical vote during the Morning Phase is not much different from actually voting in a normal game. If I were to self-hammer as a town in a normal game, that would not be making a point, that would be me willingly giving up my ability to vote and scum hunt. This is exactly what Lynx did on top of voting for coffee.↑ LynxKuroneko wrote:So now that I'm hypothetically lynched... Can we, you know, actually try to win this?
Let's start with you:To me, SSBF's post seems ingenuine. If he knows Lynx won't flip scum, it gives him a way to look like he's trying to form relationships, without actually having to do so when Lynx flips town.
VOTE: SSBF
At the time you posted this, you were under the assumption that it was plausible that Konowa and UT fake claimed neighbors (which makes no sense unless you are really bad scums) and had your vote on Konowa. By the time you switched your vote on UT/Lynx, it was clear the slot was going to be lynched. It's very convenient for scum to hide in a wagon like this to avoid accountability for an impending mislynch while attacking others for being part of the mislynch when it happens. So far, this has worked. Until now...↑ shaddowez wrote:I was having a hard time reading UT because all I was reading was ass, but I've gone back and reread. \
UT decided to drink coffee first thing, which considering it shortens the day and gives less time for discussion is a scummy thing to do. He claims he didn't understand what it did, which reduces my scumread a little bit. However, it also means he didn't pay very close attention to the rules or bother to clarify with the mod, which I always associate with scumlike behavior (My interpretation - not caring about how the game play works is less important to people that don't care very much how the day turns out). Additionally, Konowa later on goes to say that he clarified with the mod in a QT that him and UT are in, making UT's claim that he didn't know how it worked even less credible.
UT makes almost no solid points in his posts, and is very brash and offensive, not appearing to want to work with any of the players.
I'm not reading anything particularly scummy in Lynx, except for his dodging of the explanation for his claim. I'm also not seeing anything that makes him townish, so I'm willing to vote this slot.
VOTE: Lynx
VOTE: shaddowez
It's also worth noting that thestatusquo suspected shaddowez. If shaddowez is scum, I could easily see shaddowez sending in a kill for TSQ (or getting one of his scum buddies to do it) to minimize the risk of being suspected Day 2.