As in, if the 2x detective uses a shot and dies, does the backup 2x detective get 1 shot or two?
I think regardless of the answer, the setup is notably scumsided, but the answer to this affects by how much. In the former case of two shots no matter what, I'd call it beyond the range of acceptably scumsided (~65-35 scum-town I'd say), in the latter I'd call it borderline but maybe maybe
maybe
passable as scumsided but within the margin (~60-40 scum-town, which is allowed, but not recommended).