Merchant's Daughter [Endgame]

[Firebringer]

How the hell is Alisae scummy?!?

[RadiantCowbells]

I townread DT pretty hard before I looked at his iso in depth, pulling that read back and saying I really don't know.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Moment are you scum?

I can’t help get the feeling that he’s maybe confbiasing me. Are you @Moment?

[RadiantCowbells]

Alisae was null

SS is scummy

[RadiantCowbells]

Moment, TheBrie, SS, Pvturists are my strongest wolf reads as of right now. I'm very uncomfortable with how closely that aligns with sorting by post count. Hopefully one of them does something to show me that I'm wrong?

[Firebringer]

I want to be one of ur strongest wolf reads ;(

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'm literally spending hours catching up on this game. Please, just include it in another post.

I'm not entirely sure how like one off-topic post interferes with your ability to do a catchup on the intervening 60 pages? Like I'm interested in what you're saying. I know I asked about TheBrie but my questions and other comments will still be here when you finish so I'm not trying to nuke your momentum. Just do what you gotta do man

It shouldn’t and we really don’t want a repeat of last time, when 5 slots replaced out back-back.

It’s important to both keep the game fun and ontrack, which is why someone had better pick PB, because I might die of boredom otherwise.

[RadiantCowbells]

Taly I think is most likely village!

[Something_Smart]

Alisae was null

SS is scummy

I am, but that's not indicative of my alignment.

[Nancy Drew 39]

Take him into your arms and love him forever, Ank

And when you do let me know why Nancy didn't make his list

I’m not unhappy about not making his list because I’m not currently townreading him. I have 0 intention of accepting his offer, if he ever did decide to ask me anyway.

[Pink Ball]

K well I'm here but it's gonna take hours to closeread this 100 page game so don't hold your breath

I'm Kirby, I can hold my breath for a really long time

[RadiantCowbells]

Eh maybe SS is villa

Now I feelsbad about not accepting alisae dance request but e replaced out before I even read es slot

[Nancy Drew 39]

momentum

*rimshot*

Also, I've been thinking. Scum get to make someone an IC. It would help immensely if they couldn't pick someone everyone already knew was town. So it's probably not a good idea to be very vocal about your townreads. Hmm, if only there were some other thread you could post them in... :thonk:

So, yeah. Whoever dances with me, this is what we are going to be talking about. Ideally, I'd like it to be someone who also prefers townhunting to scumhunting.

I honestly don’t think it matters that much if we give our townreads, as far as that goes. But how are we supposed to sort slots without that?

[RadiantCowbells]

I really don't see a reason to townread Krazy outside of wim

[Firebringer]

has anyone read PinkBalls iso this game and just gone "wow this is a good read. 10/10 funniest best posts in this game".

[Nancy Drew 39]

oh jeez

the hopeless romantic in me wants to agree to that but the rational part of me if slapping that other part of me down to the ground

+1

Agreed. I really don’t understand the logic in that. Sharing reads doesn’t help scum, it helps town sort. So, I disagree with that line of reasoning.

[Something_Smart]

As long as people talk about the game, sorting will be possible. Doesn't mean you need a complete moratorium on discussing townreads but if most people don't do it (or at the very least, if people don't say which townreads are their strongest), it will be hard for scum to know where town's collective head is at.

[Firebringer]

has anyone read PinkBalls iso this game and just gone "wow this is a good read. 10/10 funniest best posts in this game".

not being sarcastic. PB iso is delicious.

[Nancy Drew 39]

I'm still in the mindset that if we're going with scenario 2 it's actually better strategically to not give reads in pre-dance,

SS you might want to read my early iso and bear in mind that Vedith is paired with Firebringer and Firebringer is the 8-coin lady

that being said I agree that it is best not to be clear about the exact hierarchy of your top townreads

however, you should be very focused on your bottom 3 gentlemen and your bottom 2 ladies since that will be the primary focus of discussion for dance 1, and there is no reason not to discuss them

so it's not "don't talk reads" it's "don't specify in your top 4 dudes and top 4 girls who is locktown and who is townlean" unless you have a good reason to

Yeah, there’s a clear difference between creating a hierarchy of reads and not sorting at all.

[Something_Smart]

In this case it can help both town and scum.

Or maybe an interesting twist is: don't talk about your read on your partner unless you strongly scumread them and are considering leaving. That way, if scum IC a townie with a strong townread on their partner it might turn into a town autowin.

[RadiantCowbells]

I truly don't believe that Krazy takes a viewpoint that it's good for me to come to second dance as town

Maybe I'm seeing misplaced negativity that should take be there

But I kinda see Krazy as the kind of player who would pull a Mathdino and try to prevent me bring paired with townreads and just try to get me lynched in the Poe pool

Maybe I'm reading imagined stuff into it but that's where my head is at

I'm also uncomfortable with the argument between his/ank but in that case I have problems with it happening at all on both sides and not really sure who the scummy one is? but I do get the distinct gut impression that at least one side of that debate was a wolf

[Nancy Drew 39]

the hopeless romantic in me wants to agree to that but the rational part of me if slapping that other part of me down to the ground

Take my hand and I'll convince the rational side of you.

@Ank you might want to seriously consider this. I don’t want Urist left behind. I think he should get paired up.

I townleaning him rn.

[Pink Ball]

has anyone read PinkBalls iso this game and just gone "wow this is a good read. 10/10 funniest best posts in this game".

not being sarcastic. PB iso is delicious.

Nancy I know you got some beef in the past with this bitch (female dog) but she's OUR bitch now

[RadiantCowbells]

Dannflor iso is fakeable but definitely veers heavily to town

Anyone hav scum dannflor meta?

[Nancy Drew 39]

the hopeless romantic in me wants to agree to that but the rational part of me if slapping that other part of me down to the ground

you might want to sleep on it although, given I've been listening to his recommendation of music from 2093, I'm liking Pvt on a personal level right now

I mean my read isn't more solid but he seems like a cool guy regardless of alignment

sure but I don't want to be stabbed in the back because I wasn't careful enough

I feel way more confident about Urist being town than Moment fwiw. I might even consider pairing with him myself, if you don’t want him.