Gameshow Mafia (Reroll): Game Over

[chennisden]

1 of 4 tomorrow

[Titus]

rank

This is the one power in the game my brain dries out on when I try to get it.

[Titus]

1 of 4 tomorrow

Hell no. Are you fucking scum?

[NanceFloor]

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I agree. We mathematically have got all info we can (

supposing the game isn't over

) without lynching.

[NanceFloor]

Rank
Choose by majority vote a group of two players. During that Night, the Mafia, in addition to submitting the kill, must produce an ordered list of those players such that any Mafia aligned players appear above any town aligned players in that list.

[Titus]

Rank
Choose by majority vote a group of two players. During that Night, the Mafia, in addition to submitting the kill, must produce an ordered list of those players such that any Mafia aligned players appear above any town aligned players in that list.

I still don't get how this works practically.

[Creature]

Can we do something that will actually help us solve the game tomorrow?

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I think the only power that can reveal the entire scumteam is rank, I think?

But there is no limit to how many times we can vote lynch.

So probably not, we will have to vote another power tomorrow then only the next day, can we do anything like that.

We can use vengeful

We can use arena (now that RC brought it up)

Just don't select things like protect that won't give us any info at all on anyone's alignment.

[Creature]

Rank
Choose by majority vote a group of two players. During that Night, the Mafia, in addition to submitting the kill, must produce an ordered list of those players such that any Mafia aligned players appear above any town aligned players in that list.

I still don't get how this works practically.

Town selects Player A and Player B.

If Player A and Player B are both town, mafia can rank them however they want.
If Player A is town and Player B is scum, mafia must rank Player B above Player A.
If Player A is scum and Player B is town, mafia must rank Player A above Player B.
If Player A and Player B are both scum, mafia can rank them however they want.

[NanceFloor]

Rank

Choose by majority vote a group of two players

. During that Night, the Mafia, in addition to submitting the kill, must produce an ordered list of those players such that any Mafia aligned players appear above any town aligned players in that list.

I still don't get how this works practically.

I don’t understand the first part of this. We first vote the two players with the highest scum equity, I guess. Then scum has to make a list reveal revealing the scumteam in exchange for an NK.

@mod, am I understanding this correctly?

[NanceFloor]

Rank
Choose by majority vote a group of two players. During that Night, the Mafia, in addition to submitting the kill, must produce an ordered list of those players such that any Mafia aligned players appear above any town aligned players in that list.

I still don't get how this works practically.

Town selects Player A and Player B.

If Player A and Player B are both town, mafia can rank them however they want.
If Player A is town and Player B is scum, mafia must rank Player B above Player A.
If Player A is scum and Player B is town, mafia must rank Player A above Player B.
If Player A and Player B are both scum, mafia can rank them however they want.

Oh okay, I clearly misunderstood it then.

So not worth risking an NK for that atp.

[NanceFloor]

Can we do something that will actually help us solve the game tomorrow?

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I think the only power that can reveal the entire scumteam is rank, I think?

But there is no limit to how many times we can vote lynch.

So probably not, we will have to vote another power tomorrow then only the next day, can we do anything like that.

We can use vengeful

We can use arena (now that RC brought it up)

Just don't select things like protect that won't give us any info at all on anyone's alignment.

Venge gives scum a free NK so that’s bad because if we correctly lynch scum, either RC and me will die. Moon will 100% kill either of us, so no.

Why do we ever need to use venge at all when we can select lynch indefinitely?

[Titus]

Can we do something that will actually help us solve the game tomorrow?

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I think the only power that can reveal the entire scumteam is rank, I think?

But there is no limit to how many times we can vote lynch.

So probably not, we will have to vote another power tomorrow then only the next day, can we do anything like that.

We can use vengeful

We can use arena (now that RC brought it up)

Just don't select things like protect that won't give us any info at all on anyone's alignment.

Venge gives scum a free NK so that’s bad because if we correctly lynch scum, either RC and me will die. Moon will 100% kill either of us, so no.

Why do we ever need to use venge at all when we can select lynch indefinitely?

Venge is pretty much only good in a setup where we know that scum are in a particular pool.

So if we lynch in A or B, lynch in the other scum, 1 of 4, count bodies, venge.

That's the only place I see venge being useful.

That

[chennisden]

SAVE VENGE FOR LYLO

[chennisden]

oh nvm we cant

[chennisden]

but SAVE VENGE FOR MYLO

[chennisden]

uh Rank is literally a free cop

[chennisden]

succint is literally only conf town now

[chennisden]

actually rank is worthless

[chennisden]

titus rn u dont get to call other people scum

[chennisden]

i think we can easily find the wolf in 1/4

[Titus]

titus rn u dont get to call other people scum

I do. I said I'd sheep the power pick, no matter how dumb as long as it wasn't 1 in 4.

By saving 1 in 4 until after we get scum in both pools, everyone outside the 1 in 4 is conftown.

[NanceFloor]

i think we can easily find the wolf in 1/4

Titus is right about this, because even if true, there’s still two other scum left in game and we can’t repick this, so 1/4 terrible choice for next power. Ideally, it should be used when only one scum left in the game.

[NanceFloor]

succint is literally only conf town now

Do I really need to repost that Captain Obvious meme again?

[Creature]

Can we do something that will actually help us solve the game tomorrow?

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I think the only power that can reveal the entire scumteam is rank, I think?

But there is no limit to how many times we can vote lynch.

So probably not, we will have to vote another power tomorrow then only the next day, can we do anything like that.

We can use vengeful

We can use arena (now that RC brought it up)

Just don't select things like protect that won't give us any info at all on anyone's alignment.

Venge gives scum a free NK so that’s bad because if we correctly lynch scum, either RC and me will die. Moon will 100% kill either of us, so no.

Why do we ever need to use venge at all when we can select lynch indefinitely?

Again:

Choose by majority vote a player to eliminate from the game. That player can choose another player to eliminate from the game.

Mafia cannot kill after this power

.

Unless you think we're giving scum venge, but a 1 for 1 trade still seems worth it.

[NanceFloor]

Can we do something that will actually help us solve the game tomorrow?

Something that involves actually flipping someone.

I think the only power that can reveal the entire scumteam is rank, I think?

But there is no limit to how many times we can vote lynch.

So probably not, we will have to vote another power tomorrow then only the next day, can we do anything like that.

We can use vengeful

We can use arena (now that RC brought it up)

Just don't select things like protect that won't give us any info at all on anyone's alignment.

Venge gives scum a free NK so that’s bad because if we correctly lynch scum, either RC and me will die. Moon will 100% kill either of us, so no.

Why do we ever need to use venge at all when we can select lynch indefinitely?

Again:

Choose by majority vote a player to eliminate from the game. That player can choose another player to eliminate from the game.

Mafia cannot kill after this power

.

Unless you think we're giving scum venge, but a 1 for 1 trade still seems worth it.

How? We also block NKs by not voting for powers that make them possible. Well unless you’re proposing mislynching an obvious lhf, yes. If we correctly lynch scum, you know either RC or me are the logical VK.

You’re starting to worry me again with this. :/