Newbie 2043: Cherfnul - Game Over

[clidd]

And I couldn't hide my "hmmmm" when reacting to Trendall, I was soo happy about outing cop with my genius gambit

[Trendall]

Wow, you are so smart, Trendall.

I suppose you have already discovered my evil schemes.

I mean I think I'm smart at some things, really dumb at other things. Everybody has things that they're good at and things that they're bad at, so again 'wow, you are so smart'...I could just never care about this as a concept because I just think that everybody has their own skills, and how good at something a person is is like 99% hard work anyway. If people on the internet thing I'm dumb it doesn't interest me terribly. Sorry but again if you want to get into my head, it's doable but you have to do a much better job than this.

[Trendall]

And I couldn't hide my "hmmmm" when reacting to Trendall, I was soo happy about outing cop with my genius gambit

Haha you were like 'I'll protect you this is so good!'

[LavarManos]

I'm a little confused. What is clidd saying?

[Trendall]

He's sarcastically pretending to concede lol

[clidd]

I'm already inside you head, Trendall.

And telling you that I'm scum.

[Trendall]

I've been saying that for pages and pages now so glad you're onboard.

[Trendall]

Haha you were like 'I'll protect you this is so good!'

Like you can't have not known that I screwed up and forgot roleblocker there.

[clidd]

Ok, I'm not scum, I'm rehearsing my theater skills.

[Trendall]

Very good but I still think ur maf

[clidd]

So, you are like 100% on me mafia as uncdd doctor?

[clidd]

Hum, I'm not getting from where you think I'm trying to enter your mind.

[Trendall]

I wouldn't be 100% on anything, I'd have to be able to deductively prove it for 100% and I can't do that, and you virtually never can in this game other than in situations where there's like a clear cop who has a guilty and you're working under the assumption that everyone is playing to their win condition.

[Trendall]

And other similar situations

[clidd]

I see.

[ben dover123]

I don't see anything about defeatism, and I don't understand why it is scummy in this situation. Both you and Trendall are the loudest voices in the games and also happen to be his biggest opponents. I could see him being exasperated as town here, and I don't think the way he presented his claim is likely to come from scum.

"Being extremely proactive" also including "never accepts defeatism", if you were wondering.

I'm not really an opponent, in fact I'm not sure who I support for rn. I was hard pocketed by clidd and was blinded for multiple pages.

Also:

The guy lied about doctor self-protecting, claimed doctor bizarrely early, tried to make out as though he was clear when he wasn't, can't stay consistent as to whether he's not in the mood to play or wants to do serious analysis. Tried to post-justify by pretending he was joking or trolling or whatever and now he's gonna take it seriously. He's doing everything he can to pocket ben dover123. His maf reads are on people I think are town. I can make sense of who his partner would be and why. He claimed doctor day one - I've been in two games very recently where the mafia claimed doctor day one so he's just like...carrying out the maf strategy as I'd expect somebody to at this point. After a point it's just like 'yeah I've seen enough it's probably this guy who's mafia' and there's absolutely no point in thinking about it more than that because you'll just overthink urself into oblivion.

[ben dover123]

Most notably, I see that clidd is very inconsistent, something that doesn't transfer from his meta. I'm not sure why he keeps on backtracking on his own arguments, it's not like this is him not having played mafia for a while, backtracking over your own arguments is pretty "whut" kind of thing.

[clidd]

Well, I think we were going on the right track with my poe.

But I'll respect both opinions here.

[ben dover123]

clidd, why did you pocket me again?

[clidd]

Maybe I'm enjoying playing the villain role.

[ben dover123]

Maybe I'm enjoying playing the villain role.

That's all you are going to say?

Stop trying to nag us inside our heads.

[clidd]

I mean, all this discussion has interrupted my line of reasoning.

I don't even remember where I was in the Jumble replacement assessment.

[ben dover123]

I mean, all this discussion has interrupted my line of reasoning.

I don't even remember where I was in the Jumble replacement assessment.

Can I have a actual direct answer to why you pocketed me or are you is post 969 your reason.

[clidd]

Because you need to be pocket so we can work together to solve.

Trendall is a distraction here.

[ben dover123]

I'm still reluctant to eliminate clidd because he could turn out to be a confirmed town...
I should look at some other possible eliminations.

Because you need to be pocket so we can work together to solve.

Trendall is a distraction here.

You sure warped me really hard for a pocket...

Then who is scum in your eyes?