I don't see any better option right now.In post 948, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:you’ve explicitly stated you don’t have any actual reasons to scumread us other than poe. so why are you inviting others to join our wagon?In post 947, T3 wrote:Would you be willing to vote TLDNE wjith me?
- lilith
oh? i thought you were disagreeing with fairy here on titus being town.In post 917, T3 wrote:This is sort of reminding me of LN235 but Fairy is saying this is town Titus?
I think all of it points pretty strongly toward him actually having no potions. When I say townslip I was assuming that scum got a factional stock of potions like the last game; I will have to double-check that, because I realize that I might be wrong about it.In post 956, RCEnigma wrote:the initial bingle posting his ingredient or the realization bit about ingredients not being consistent?
implies that bingle has a potion....with an ingredient. did he claim to be potionless and i missed it?In post 321, Bingle wrote:Just poison. I was implying I might have more than one in case Schadd told me this setup had closed elements to obscure information, but it turns out the ingredients are publicly a red herring.In post 313, mastina wrote:Oh you have ingredients in your role PM?
In post 717, Bingle wrote:The sample potionless role PM matches mine except I got poison as an ingredient instead of a stolen crate. Poison is included as an ingredient in the Harmography potion (and only the harmography potion) in the OP. That's why I thought there might be a way to combine ingredients into potions.In post 715, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:er, no. the ingredients lists literally have zero impact on the game. honestly I’m confused how you can have an ingredient without a potion.. but then none of this is making much sense to me.
- lilith
- lilithIn post 831, Bingle wrote:First:
My role PM had poison specifically called an ingredient, in lieu of the crate of bottles.
Second:
Yes. Given the information from my role PM, I DID assume there was an additional mechanic of potion ingredient combination. That's pretty self evident. Entirely lacking in your questioning is why that's a specifically scum misunderstanding.
Third:
Yes. I've explicitly been using tools from my scum toolbox. Because I'm not a shitty player and my scum toolbox and town toolbox are remarkably similar toolboxes. (FWIW, my town toolbox is a subset of my scum toolbox, because there are some things that are effective as scum (laying false associatives, for example) that just don't have a town use). Your argument is about as relevant as arguing that me buddying someone is scum indicative, when more than most the way to read me is by looking at my results. Ask yourself this: Am I driving this thread in a direction where it is easier or harder for town to solve it?
Now that we've got that out of the way:
What do you make of Titus/RCE/Dwlee?
Dwlee specifically has been giving me flashbacks to Draft, where he was scum defending me from Titus in lieu of defending himself, and I want to know if you see the same thing.
I do disagree. It was a noticeable but ineffective defense. Usually not something to come from scumpartnes.In post 953, RCEnigma wrote:oh? i thought you were disagreeing with fairy here on titus being town.In post 917, T3 wrote:This is sort of reminding me of LN235 but Fairy is saying this is town Titus?
idk anything about the potion distribution, someone did back bingle up with the logic that he would have just checked the ingredients against partners ingredients in scum pt and i dont think its possible scum only ends up with 1 potion though. so i think that defense holds some weight, more than him being town for claiming to be potionless.In post 958, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:I think all of it points pretty strongly toward him actually having no potions. When I say townslip I was assuming that scum got a factional stock of potions like the last game; I will have to double-check that, because I realize that I might be wrong about it.In post 956, RCEnigma wrote:the initial bingle posting his ingredient or the realization bit about ingredients not being consistent?
-S
maybe lol, i already had my change of heart I dont want to murder your slot.
It's in the OP. Scum are significantly more likely to have potions than town.In post 966, RCEnigma wrote:idk anything about the potion distribution
>_>In post 958, The Limit Does Not Exist wrote:When I say townslip I was assuming that scum got a factional stock of potions like the last game; I will have to double-check that, because I realize that I might be wrong about it.