First things first- I am a night owl, so except posts from me during the night. i dont post much during the day- a job and whatnot. If it is a problem, just say so. I’ll also answer questions directed to me no matter how old the questions are.
---
Things of note: (I'm typing this as i read through)
-------------
jdm vs redFF
RedFF sounds sincere, but misguided to me, here. jdm is getting pissed at redFF’s apparent rush to lynch. I like this post here. sounds town to me
↑ jdm998 wrote:
Why are you so quick to lynch bruv? A miller NEEDS to say they're a miller. RBT's done that. Nothing scummy about that to me. Maybe you play different, but every game I've been in, miller's have claimed. A name cliam would be cool, but right now you're just jumping to lynch right away, and if we mislynch then somebody gets nighkilled we'd be in a bad spot. Stop overreacting right away, it's annoying and works against us.
This argument was more likely town on town in my opinion.
----------------------
IS vs RBT
Meta things flow. I find it interesting that IS called RBT out for being scum in many of his games, and pointed out that RBT makes idiotic gambits when scum, all the while nelgecting the fact that he was scum in those games also (according to RBT- dont sue me if this insight turns out to be false)
------------------------
IS vs jason
This looks like IS is just poing at jason to see what sticks. I would call IS scummy for this but... i did read some of IS’s games in the past and the posting style is similar. I guess I’ll just wait and see with IS.
---------------------
IS- what’s the significance of “vote #3”? it is 7 to lynch, amirite? Doesnt look like a “sneaky way to quicklynch you” to me.
--------
redFF- I could think of a couple characters that’d fit a miller role- but what the other thing we could do with RBT is to just treat the millerclaim as a nulltell, and wait, see if somebody claims RBT’s name, then see what happens after that? Naturally, if RBT is scummy, ropey time. If towny, RBT can live. I dont think a millerclaim is a good D1 lynch because it is not really revealing of any algnment. Its essetinaly a policy lynch which allows both town and scum to have nearly the same motives on that wagon, which is bad. If we lynch based on something scummy, we’ll have information afterwards based on who was on/off the wagon.
------
Smallpeoples343 is a bit odd to me. “really weird millerclaim” how so? and this post is... I dont see the point of it.
↑ smallpeoples343 wrote:Usually, a complete claim involves a roleclaim and a nameclaim in themed games, to verify the role with the flavor name.
The +1 of IS’s post is hilarious. use your own brain, dont borrow posts from IS.
My god. you post 2 huge quotes to just point at a little thing that could vaguely be condisered a contradiction? that was a waste of a post.
a quick takeback of your wasted post with no explantion of why you thought it was a contradiction?
You, my friend, are scum.
For more references- just look at his posting in iso- he contributes nothing of any substance, just little pointing fingers and no votes. /dislike.
unvote, vote smallpeople
---------
Pine- I think it’d be more useful to ask that question to the mod AFTER somebody nameclaimed, not before. by asking before, you’re ensuring scum doesnt mess up on their nameclaims. scumpoint to you here i think. not major, but a little.
----------------
jdm- I dont get the point of this post.
↑ jdm998 wrote:
For reference:
Not day 1 claiming a potential power role (I've been in games where the trade off is a miller has a power ie: The Punisher is a vigilante) is not scummy, just a bit suspicous
Voting somebody for not day 1 claiming a potential power role (See above) is scummy.
In my eyes.
----------
To TLDR for wall-skimmers, read the section on smallpeoples. that's the important section i think. He's a sneaky scummy ghost. let's bust him.