Starting off at the first few pages, Senjai reads town to me. His curt answers on the question of it being the first page and his blatant admission that he wanted to prolong the RVS stage definitely come from a town mindset. I'd expect scum to be a little more agreeable regarding RVS. Piggy's
29 comes off as scummy because she doesn't seem to understand why Senjai is towntelling. Although we now know Piggy is town, so looking at it from that perspective, Nero Cain's
30 comes off as even more scummy to me since he questions both Piggy and Senjai. While questioning is good, it is the motivation behind those questions that can come off as town or scum. In this case, the fact that Nero Cain isn't committing to a position but rather equivocating on which side to take is scummy. This leaves him flexible to choose whichever side the wind blows.
The following exchange between Piggy and Plan B makes Plan B look good and Piggy look bad, with Piggy's reasoning for a Senjai town-read relatively weak. Interesting that N popped up just at that moment to ask who is lurking. It was only page 3 but it struck me as somewhat self-conscious. I like Demon Care's vote on Nero Cain at that point especially as I was reading Nero as leaning scum at that point.
Nero's vote on Senjai was bad - voted just because Senjai asked for it. Toon Fighter's accusation of Piggy chainsaw defending Senjai was poorly thought out as well. JacobSavage's "Piggy is nervous town" seems like a lot of whiteknighting. How would JacobSavage know that Piggy is "nervous town" as opposed to "nervous scum." Looks more like an excuse to have a townread on a likely mislynch. My scumreads so far: ToonFighter, NeroCain, JacobSavage.
Coming to page 3, Plan B's questioning of JacobSavage was right on the mark. Add him to the list of townreads along with Senjai. Senjai's
52 is very pro-town. His aggression in trying to figure out who scum is on his wagon reads completely as town. ToonFighter conitnues using bad arguments and JacobSavage isn't able to articulate what about Piggy he finds townish. He calls Piggy town because Piggy is jumpy - again bad reasoning. Plan B's
65, I agree with. Doom's post reads null.
The first thing that made me question my scumread on JacobSavage is DoomYoshi's questioning of him on page 4 - but I'll chalk it down to distancing at this point. JacobSavage's
91 is terrible. A lot of manufactured reads that don't really make any sense. The fact that Nero Cain considers multi-posting a scumtell is hilarious.
Liking page 5 JacobSavage wagon. I find it funny that Nero Cain defends Jacob Savage and asks why he is scummy for calling someone "nervous town." The reason is that Jacob savage couldn't have known for a fact that Piggy is town and he also uses scumtells like being jumpy as towntells. Jacob should probably have been lynched last Day. Doom's
168 seems like distancing. No vote for JacobSavage, just incredulity at his posts and a general air of pretend-antagonism. Jacob Savage was at L-3 and the Piggywagon on page came at a very opportune time and looks like a potential counterwagon to JacobSavage. If Jacob flips scum, some of the latecomers to the Piggywagon should be examined more closely.
I like catching up to long games half at a time. This is my analysis of the first 10 pages. I'll post analysis on the next 10 pages and probably vote then.
I just looked back and realized that GentlemenBastards replaced Senjai. So far:
1) GentlemenBastards - Town
2) Plan B - Town
3) N - Null
4) 4nxi3ty - Null
5) Empking - Null
6) RedCoyote - Null
7) Untrod Tripod - Null
8) adorkable - Null
9) Toon Fighter - Scum
10) Nero Cain - Scum
11) JacobSavage - Scum
I'll fill in the null reads after I finish the next 10 pages.
