Newbie 1391 - Game Over - FINALLY!!!

[Feel It]

Either way,

vote feel it

You can now explain your panicky reaction when I took nacho out of L-1 and took away your ability to hammer him, and put it on a now confirmed scum player.

And if you use at any time the arguement you were voting for antagon I will push this lynch with everything I have. Bussing does not clear anybody.

Are you seriously retarded? I've explained this a thousand times. Get over your tunneling you're just hurting the town now with your narrow mindedness. Push my lynch if you want but you're gonna look very, very stupid when I flip town.

VOTE: chkflip

The games practically won, it's obvious Fegelin backed out because he was scum and he know the game was over for him.

[Generic]

You were giving intent to hammer nacho if I remember correctly.

Now you are insulting me and telling everyone game is wrapped up. You have all the answers don't you.

[Feel It]

Go look at your own play you've tunneled so hard you've lost your common sense. Reread the game, particularly Fegelin and add up all the facts, his subtle buddying , his tunneling on Nacho (who's pretty unlikely to be scum now). The guy completely disappeared when Antagon went under pressure. And to top it off once we lynched his buddy he gave up and got a replacement, he's like the most obvious lynch ever.

I was obviously wrong about giving intent to hammer Nacho. I was probably wrong about Gen_Wolf being scum as well.

[chkflip]

VOTE: Feel It

325 is heinous for several reasons. Soft-claiming, flailing, the reasons Generic just gave, and giving no proclamation himself as to why I'm scum.

PEDIT: Last I checked, tunneling and active lurking are both null in most cases. And it's hilarious to me that you're setting up tomorrow's lynch on Gen_Wolf when it should be very clear to you, by your accusatory tone in 325, that I'm 100% scum and should end the game with a successful lynch on my slot.

[chkflip]

EBWODP: "giving no proclamation" can be struck from the record since his reason is that my slot buddied, tunneled, and lurked.

Cool story, bro. Tell it again.

[chkflip]

69 and 72 are extremely baseless and complete WIFOM fluff. I'm very confident in my vote and will begin to draw up a case on Feel It when I'm not at work.

[Feel It]

VOTE: Feel It

lol, fine lynch me. There's still enough townies to finish you.

[chkflip]

No defense so he self-votes. And we're supposed to see this AtE as town. Right.

[Feel It]

Why are you complaining? I'm just helping you.

[chkflip]

No complaints, I'm calling it like it is.

[champinoman]

Nice result overnight! and crazy shenanigans this morning already. This is just me checking in and I'll be back after work tonight to post my thoughts. Can't really post substantially at work.

But while I'm here;

Chkflip

, can you please give your thoughts on all players after your read through.

Off topic: Chkflip, good to see you again. You were in the other game I played here.

[Generic]

Self voting?

Adding that to the pathetic attitude feel it and my enjoyment for this game much like another on this site is disappearing fast. So many people around here who like to put nastiness into it.

unvote

You got what you wanted out of it. I will be

V/LA

from mafiascum in full while I assess whether I make these three games I'm in my last here.

[Feel It]

Sounds like you lost your nerve and can't admit it.

[Nachomamma8]

I'm a little unsure about how much of James May's posts to read into when looking at my read on StubbsKVM. Maybe someone would like to share their opinion on that if they have any good tips?

Predecessor posts usually don't figure much into my read on people unless they were strong reads; otherwise, they likely replaced out because I couldn't get a read on them and the responsive person I can actually interact with is who I'm going to focus reading most.

Unfortunately for the rest of us, our suspicions about her actions seemed to have caused her to stop posting as much and I think this might be a disservice to us in the long run.

I can't say I understand the point you're trying to make about her here. Do you think that we should fake suspect her so she posts more or that it's suspicious that she posts less when we're not suspecting her or...?

Gen_Wolf and Fegelein: How are we expected to get decent reads on people when they don't post anything in the last week. There have been 3 meaningful posts between them. I'll have another look at them both tomorrow and look back at their play over the first week. No time to do it right now.

They haven't posted much, yeah, but I think they've posted enough to read by now.

No value whatsoever.

Claiming it means it won't help town in night phase, mafia aim elsewhere. Mafia wouldn't aim at town antagon cos his play has been anti town and no threat to them. And now he is absent...

Not good enough,

vote: antagon

I will put this one on me. No way am I accepting that crap as a good defence.

^^^
This makes Generic incredibly, incredibly town. He didn't even give Antagon any time to pull out any counterclaims, which is the entire point of fakeclaiming a power role in the first place.

The guy completely disappeared when Antagon went under pressure.

He wasn't really around for the entire game.

Sounds like you lost your nerve and can't admit it.

He's taking a step back and giving you a chance to talk and explain yourself. Take it.

[Vel-Rahn Koon]

Vote Count 2.1

chkflip - 1 (Miss Stranger)
Feel It - 2 (chkflip, Feel It)

Not Voting - 5 (champinoman, Generic, Gen_Wolf, Nachomamma8, StubbsKVM)

5 to Lynch.

Deadline is in (expired on 2013-07-17 07:00:00)

.

[Miss Stranger]

Except Feel It didn't wagon Antagon when he had no other choice, he was the second person to vote him, and didn't change his mind. The fake hammer intent was a stupid way to pressure Nacho into activity, but I'm prone to believe it was simply that - stupid. Not scummy enough.

You however are starting to nitpick his ISO and that's a very classic scourge play. I'm sorry but before you get started on that, I'd like to account for yourself and not sheep Generic. Thank you.

@Nachomamma:

champino thought I was posting less because everyone hated on my walls o'text and that discouraged and intimidated me. In fact, I was preoccupied in real life, so feel free to ignore that point of his. ^^;

[Miss Stranger]

Scourge = scum. DLG slip. :<

[Generic]

This is your first game stranger?

Post 340, mainly that first paragraph, was perfect summary. Wonderful.

vote: chkflip

Logical choice, and we have plenty of room for error so lets do it.

[Nachomamma8]

Scourge = scum. DLG slip. :<

if you and Generic keep this up for much longer i'll have a whole new mafia vocabulary that is friendly to phones!

[Miss Stranger]

@Generic:

You could say it's my fo..ur..irst game? I've had one as a doc (late replacement, lost), one as a mafia roleblock (lost) and one as a sort of town investigative role (mod-abandoned). Looong time ago. D:

@Nachomamma:

Ask and you shall receive :3

[Miss Stranger]

Um, post #340 was addressed to

@chkflip

if anyone was wondering who is "you".

[Miss Stranger]

Except Feel It didn't wagon Antagon when he had no other choice, he was the second person to vote him, and didn't change his mind. The fake hammer intent was a stupid way to pressure Nacho into activity, but I'm prone to believe it was simply that - stupid. Not scummy enough.

You however are starting to nitpick his ISO and that's a very classic scourge play. I'm sorry but before you get started on that, I'd like to account for yourself and not sheep Generic. Thank you.

There, for reference.

[Generic]

Well you will be winning one I reckon this time... Assuming you are town that is

[Gen_Wolf]

just to confirm chkflip replaced feg hey? We have a lynch or two to mess around with so I am happy with a Feg (now chck?) or feel it? The self vote does give town vibes but could just be a double bluff

[champinoman]

Unfortunately for the rest of us, our suspicions about her actions seemed to have caused her to stop posting as much and I think this might be a disservice to us in the long run.

I can't say I understand the point you're trying to make about her here. Do you think that we should fake suspect her so she posts more or that it's suspicious that she posts less when we're not suspecting her or...?

Miss Stranger explained this but I wanted to post on it myself as well. I was concerned that she had stopped posting because people kept complaining about her walls of text. Turns out she was just busy.

I am still waiting to hear the thoughts from chkflip because currently I believe he needs to provide us a reason not to vote for him. He needs to reply to Miss Stranger's post #311 and explain to us why Fegelein wasn't the next lynch.