And I'm not assuming she has no reason. I've asked her repeatedly to give her reason. Which she seems unable to do. A serious vote isn't a RVS vote. The two don't correlate.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
In post 101, waynegg wrote:And I'm not assuming she has no reason. I've asked her repeatedly to give her reason. Which she seems unable to do. A serious vote isn't a RVS vote. The two don't correlate.
In post 38, waynegg wrote:A baseless vote is supposed to be taken as serious why?
He gave reads unprompted, and his reasons for his reads weren't great (vibes, gut, little bit of meta) but he acknowledged that the reasons were weak and gave them anyway. He's town.
So town give weak READS?
The fuck is this SHIT?
Heard of Paranoid townie SYNDROME?
Reasons being shit don't MEAN.
That a dude is TOWN.
Desperado wrote:
In post 101, waynegg wrote:And I'm not assuming she has no reason. I've asked her repeatedly to give her reason. Which she seems unable to do. A serious vote isn't a RVS vote. The two don't correlate.
In post 38, waynegg wrote:A baseless vote is supposed to be taken as serious why?
This early? Hell yeah they do. Did you expect him to have strong reads on page two?
And it's not that the reasons were shit, it's that he acknowledged the weakness of the reasons and gave them anyway. He doesn't care if someone thinks his weak reads are scummy, he's going to get them out there anyway.
Calling something serious doesn't make it serious. She said it was serious, which implies she has a reason. If she has a reason she should be able to provide that reason. Since she can't provide that reason, her vote can only be taken as baseless. My original question to her is simply asking for that reason, since she says she has one.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
In post 108, Who wrote:Wayne, does arguing semantics help the town in any way?
And Sakura has provided a reason.
Where has she provided a reason? Please quote.
And it does when it provides understanding of where the attack is coming from.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
Calling something serious doesn't make it serious. She said it was serious, which implies she has a reason. If she has a reason she should be able to provide that reason. Since she can't provide that reason, her vote can only be taken as baseless. My original question to her is simply asking for that reason, since she says she has one.
A reason is still a reason. Implied reason without reason is still scum.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
In post 69, Sakura Hana wrote:It is proven that scum doesn't know how to read, let alone they use their inability to read to push for mislynches with bad reasoning.
She had the same reason as SD, that you not wanting to take the time to decode Boxxy's restriction was not townie.
@Desperado
I would say that if something is only done in response to a question it removes any inherent towniness from doing it. Though I am with Jason that not being afraid to give weak reasons does not necessarily make someone town.
In post 98, waynegg wrote:So Jason, you find nothing at all scummy about a player saying they have a reason for taking an action and then failing to be able to even begin said reason? Because right now, Sakura is voting for me because I pressed for her reason which has STILL not been given for voting me. And you feel like that's sum good town postingz from her. Check...
If you really feel that way, then watch for it again, and if they do it again, you may have a point.
Right now the point you are pushing is <less relevant>.
So THAT'S how I've helped to pop scum D1 in every game I've played on site..., though I've still yet to draw a scum role with around 30 games.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
In post 98, waynegg wrote:So Jason, you find nothing at all scummy about a player saying they have a reason for taking an action and then failing to be able to even begin said reason? Because right now, Sakura is voting for me because I pressed for her reason which has STILL not been given for voting me. And you feel like that's sum good town postingz from her. Check...
If you really feel that way, then watch for it again, and if they do it again, you may have a point.
Right now the point you are pushing is <less relevant>.
Good point.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?
In post 13, SalmonellaDoctor wrote:Mitzi's picture doesn't look like an actual post restriction, just a joke (that almost flew over my head).
As for the morse code, it looks like it says "obviously scum," but with a typo.
~SD
I think SD/Mitzi are partners based on this, and it's the only thing so far that I can really get a read on, besides feeling that the waynegg/Sakura argument is TvS.
Wayne's reading...odd, but I think he's trying, he's just decided the quickest way to the market down the street was to create a causality portal and tesseract between the two spaces rather than walking. down. the street. ~ Ghostlin Like LEGO minifigs?