In post 55, Medea the Alien wrote:I vaguely like that Hanzo_5 basically made two RVS votes. Not sure why mollie's atypically ceding D1 hydra control to Bert, and hydra head impersonation shenanigans don't help.
Don't love this. Nothing I can put my finger on. Cabd's probably going to have a better handle on him for now though.
Mina, null or scum on Osseus?
Mala's about as town as I've ever seen her.
--PA
I actually thought it was Mollie because she was around posting elsewhere. Which really mindfucks any read I wanted to throw on that slot. I hate mindgames in general.
I don't take much into that quote from Chamber, tbf. Maybe for me it's knowing how he plays from a hydra or just in general. (I can go more in depth here if you like.)
In post 56, Mina wrote:
Malakittens:
1) What do you disagree on re: Medea and bazinga? I don't think I ever committed to a read on bazinga (it's pending on how they answer some questions).
2) Please elaborate:
In post 52, Malakittens wrote:I think it was genuinely Mollie, but I'm now questioning it also. I can sometimes be right or wrong on reading her in forum mafia and this post by Bert makes me question whatever I had been feeling on the slot in general.
This whole thing is really vague and hedging. What had you "been feeling on the slot" before Bert's post? Also, "I can sometimes be right or wrong on reading her" is completely meaningless.
3) You're adorable. Just thought you should know. <3
1. I disagree on Medea because I can sometimes read PA half better than I could ever read the cabd half of the hydra. Cabd being trolly in his OP isn't something I see as alignment indicative. (However my past experience in trying to read PA went sour because I recently mislynched her Day 1 in a completed game because I thought her lurking when she was posting elsewhere was alignment indicative of her being scum and only appearing after I called her out on it.) So basically Medea is null to me rather than how you have them leaning scum.
2. You will probably see that a lot when it comes to Mollie also. I tend to hedge a lot on my read to her because she's recently been able to impersonate her town meta into her scum meta. I do *think* I might have two recent new scum tells of hers, but I need to wait in order to prove them. One of the things Bert did (more specially post
33 made me pretty sure that was Mollie posting in general. Mollie has a tendency to post like that when it comes to me. I was pretty sure she was town based on p1 and up to the point before Bert posted what he posted. You say that me saying "I could be right or wrong on reading her" is meaningless to you, but it's not and it's 100% true. Most recent scum game of Mollie I basically defended her from a lynch because I was pretty damn sure she was town and it's not the first time I have done that either so I do know for sure she's pretty good at fooling me and I like to poke at her before declaring a super read on her. (Paranoia I guess.)
3. You are adorable too<3.
In post 58, Ampersand wrote:Vote: Mina
For future reference, all of our posts will be made jointly, which does mean we won't be posting during working hours.
Not really liking the naked vote.
In post 64, BROseidon wrote:26 by Mala and the tailend of
27 about "why hydra x" is bad and should feel bad.
Obligatory fakeclaiming masons with Cabd. Too bad kuribo/DGB aren't in the game.
Rest of Mina interactions read okay.
Chamber's probably town.
VOTE: EVIL KITTIES
Why is the post bad, is it because you think I read too much into it? I get annoyed when people call out hydras in general and it's not like this game isn't full of hydras because it is. The vote looked lazy as fuck on Bert/Mollie.
In post 65, Hanzo_5 wrote:
@Malakittens, why is post
25 stupid?
Yes I realize there is more than one hydra playing.
First you voted lazy, imo. Second, you came into this game knowing there was hydra's. I'm kinda interested to see if you have had this hydra hate in prior games of yours or if it's just a new thing. Third, I was townreading that hydra at the time so it felt off.
I just hated the fact you singled that hydra out.
In post 68, bazinga wrote:Sorry guys, my brain was fried last night and I was messing around.
Those post were precisely what I would say if I were impersonating Mollie, and I just wanted to have a little fun at the beginning. Regrettably, it is true Mollie has not posted in this game yet.
In post 56, Mina wrote:Mala just doesn't strike me as a particularly confident or vocal player in general.
From past games, I know that she can be rather confident if she thinks she's right.
It was my signal that I knew he/she was joking about the investigation results. Instead of pointing out how there was no N0 and that scum don't scumclaim like that, I played along and waited to see how people would dismiss his/her case on his/herself.
Yeah, I kinda want to hate your guts for impersonating her. I hate mindgames which has already been stated. I tend to use early pages to read out Mollie than in later pages and you kinda fucked it up for me. Now with my luck, I'll be questioning which head is posting for the reminder of the game.
Yeah; so you basically used Mina's posts the same way I was to gauge reactions of others.
In post 70, Ghatokaca wrote:Penguin, what about Mala seems town to you?
Malakittens, why do you refer to yourself as "lynchbait?" I got the opposite impression from your play in the only game we played together.
So far, I am getting townvibes from Mina. I don't think the gambit makes her town or scum, but I feel that her posts and analysis since then are advancing the gamestate, and the way she is giving out reads and questioning players feels genuine.
I dislike ToastyToast's
66. Toasty, if they are experienced players, would they not be comfortable putting themselves out there as scum?
~ F-16
I haven't been playing well in recent games and I'm pretty easily seen as lynchbait. (at least in my opinion.) I have my own difference of opinion in that game because I played really bad by pushing a lynch on a player because I thought he was scum and then letting one scum off the hook and not knowing which way to go when you/Nacho&Bert were arguing.
I also *thought* I was responding to Mollie and I *thought* she was referencing a f2f mafia joke rather than a site joke because unless I was a mason I was lynched in most games in F2F mafia during the reckoning.