Mini 1566: Lunar Silver Star Story Complete (Game Over)

[Jake from State Farm]

Now you lost will you self vote?

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

first is active lurking, not trolling and the last four are Bert. the second one isn't even trolling.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

TRY AGAIN

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

~~~ = sarcasm

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

in the sweetest possible manner

[Jake from State Farm]

They all are trolling especially #2

[sangres]

I feel like Aegor in particular is really benefiting from all the noise in the thread.

[sangres]

Yes, Kdub, that is correct.


So I want SMP dead, and then HS. Also catboi.

Why do you want SMP dead?

[Jake from State Farm]

We really should be lynching hkc/smp/shroom guaranteed 2 scum in this pool

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Spoiler:

Mara is not here right now. Please leave a message after the beep.

sangres (fferyllt + Nachomamma8)
PhDScar
Mac

ActionDan
Aegor

HighShroomish
SMP
catboi
Kdub

BROseidon

Aj The Epic
Jake From State Farm


enjoy this complementary mara post as I take my leave

When's the last time you've had a hydra partner unexpectantly drop you in a game, jake?

and, if my post was the reason you have your vote on us, why did it take for bert to say something for the vote to get dropped in the first place?

I have roughly 40 minutes before I have to go and leave to catch the bus! answer quick plzandthxu

I don't watch football, I wouldn't know.

how is my question irrelavant, and why are you ignoring the follow up?

dear gods you're slow. I'm giving you my time in a game I don't really even wanna be in. don't waste it

I was unaware of the fact that our hydra had been signed up for any recent games and the simple question of "why am I in this game" is boring and probably wouldn't get me a wholotta reactions and I likesme some reactions

why are you ignoring the followup?

Why?

what do you think of jake now?

that was to scar

JAKE WHY ARE YOU IGNORING THE OTHER QUESTION

Scar: If you're concerned about an opportunistic wagon occuring, what do you think of the one that is happening on the claimed PR?

I've read it, and I still don't get it

:/

and now I must leave, joy

sangres (fferyllt + Nachomamma8)
PhDScar
Mac

ActionDan

Aegor

HighShroomish
SMP
catboi
Kdub

BROseidon

Aj The Epic

Jake From State Farm


enjoy this complementary mara post as I take my leave

updated

Pedit: it might be. but the wagon isn't

and, if my post was the reason you have your vote on us, why did it take for bert to say something for the vote to get dropped in the first place?

Why are you assuming that? Bert had nothing to do with the timing of my vote

Because... you placed your vote after qyoting bert vs having voted as soon as my post happened?

And I am female, i'll project my emotions wherever he fuck I like. Ive already spent the entire night yelling at bert anyhow and Im not replacing out because I cant really do that to bork (aside the fact that I would never do that as scum cuz pride so doing it now would be pretty much be a trust tell)

Scar: If you're concerned about an opportunistic wagon occuring, what do you think of the one that is happening on the claimed PR?

Are talking the maso-lover-otherrandomjunk-thingy? Because I thought that was a joke.

Is your decisive read on me in the same vein as your decisive read on k dub scar?

No matter what one it is, you are still my strongest scum read and I think you need more votes.

Yeah, the claim is bogus but that doesnt effect the wagon and how crappy it really is. all the votes are naked and done in a somewhat opportunistic matter, which is what you were concerned about in the first place. right?

A joke that was ripped off of cbd. I know, but he timimg is still weird

KODAK MOMENT

How long does it take to read through 3 pages of 1 liners?

Ok. Get back to me when you do

I wasn't talking to you

OH ALSO

you've played enough with berth and I separately to know that I don't do forced shut as scum and bert is.... being bert

But 5 hours?

Im pretty sure you've played at least one game with me

There ate three votes on us

what makes it seem like a reaction vote?

(AJ, Jake, and Aegor)

I'll go find the game, I think its an normal or qn open, but im pretty sure Ive played with you, Jake.

Re bert, he is still being bert

I know your general meta, and that your play here is different from your norm

I was town, started as me and ended up as plague with nacuo

Town hated

and I was able to recognize you as town pretty handily (though I did think tammy was scum so...)

She was town in Walking Dead.

And two and a half men

and slendy

and inheritance

I think I had you as town in Two and a half men...

Yates simply outplayed me (and the town but whatever) in Slendy.

you were pushing me like there was no tomorrow in two and a half men, but yeah I was town in walking dead and my play there was like, the climax of my town games that I can only dream of ever getting back to

VOTE: Aegor

VOTE: Bro

UNVOTE:

VOTE: Jake

Scar's town as fuck, yo

and if we were scum, we did what we did to purposefully muddy waters and make this game godimpossible to read, not to be written off as town/useless... I mean, who thinks that?

AJ: Logically, sure but I havn't really done anything alignment indicative so far, and nothing on my end should be readable as such

Bro: two games with AFB (town in both and you both derptunneled me) and one other with you outside the newbie game. It was an Open (and I think I was town there)

I have a more than marginal preference over Jake, but that'll prolly never happen unless I take hold of this hydra (and that is defintely not gonna happen). His post is like the highlight of post saying one thing, yet tone inferring something that is completly opposite of what is being said which is the scummiest kind of dissonance in the UNIVERSE and has a high ratio of actually being scum... like 99.99% chance

(I mean, this is literally the exact same thing I tagged on yates, Aj. I don't even care about your alignment right now, I can always sort you out later. I just want you to listen to me JUST ONCE even if it may possibly end up with you bussing)

though, the bussing is probably unlikely, looking at your reasons for jaketown

Making shit up?

no

but now you're just outright discrediting something solid

Especially when it comes to someone who is emotionally irrational, and is on par with my irrational paranoia? when it comes to someone who knows enough of their play style to (probably) be able to replicate their scum game as town? Especially someone who has a unique way of thinking?

Doctor Scar is town, and I yelled at my partner for wanting to kill you. reasons will have to stay with partner, though. at least for now

(first part was to Jake, and I'm well aware of the exaggeration of percentages but that doesn't change the fact that I have used it to a high success in the past)

(btw I still haven't collected my Mara hydra).

Maria&Luigi

pedit: yes. yes we do

Of course not. Do me a favor. If you are up to it. Read The Fall mafia and tell me causing chaos in the thread isn't a valuable strategy. Not only did I survive end game, I managed to get a town pr lynched and discredited.

Smart players know how to manipulate their environment.

Yes, chaos IS good. For scum. Decidedly not good for town.

Scar's town as fuck, yo

and if we were scum, we did what we did to purposefully muddy waters and make this game godimpossible to read, not to be written off as town/useless... I mean, who thinks that?

DrScar, you called AD opportunistic voting Jake - why have you ignored the fact that Aegor and Jake were trying to policy lynch HKC, and in particular the fact that Jake is parking his vote there in an effort to be as anti-town as possible?

Since when is voting for my top scum read anti-town

I'm eager to see you explain that

It's the reasons for your scum read that make the vote pretty anti-town. Though I'd probably just go ahead and call the vote scummy, myself.

I want the blood of the insurance company salesman.

Ffery, can we have it?

I mean, Aegor makes a fine second choice, though I'm a little freaked out by the fact that his play has striking resemblance to how I approached Perpetual mylo before I went all mafia-fu and nearly called out the scum team. Never mind the fact that his votes are closely following jakes

Because it takes more than once vote to spill blood?

and if you actually

read

my post, you would see that I have nacho/ffery as town

Of course not. Do me a favor. If you are up to it. Read The Fall mafia and tell me causing chaos in the thread isn't a valuable strategy. Not only did I survive end game, I managed to get a town pr lynched and discredited.

Smart players know how to manipulate their environment.

Yes, chaos IS good. For scum. Decidedly not good for town.

Scar's town as fuck, yo

and if we were scum, we did what we did to purposefully muddy waters and make this game godimpossible to read, not to be written off as town/useless... I mean, who thinks that?

Im not getting it. What's your point.

Chaos is good for scum.

as scum, we are purposefully causing chaos to make the game-state optimal for us. not to be read off as town/useless

"good scum" also know how to manipulate their environment Ironically enough the "good scum" of this hydra isn't even actively doing so and there is in thread proof that she's told her hydra partner to stop doing so

while jake is calling us scum, his story to why we are scum continually changes and still gives a contradictory message to what is actually going on...

Pedit: ok. I'm buddying so that I can get the scum-lynch I want. Also, I like town-blocks especially when it includes those I'm familiar with

Uhh... yeah, it has

You're original story was

"they are going out of their way to make themselves look town by stating they are town"

then, you said "They are clogging up the thread and thus, trying to look town"

then you called us a policy lynch, vs an actual scum lynch

and then you went back to calling us scum for being blatantly anti-town?

Useless posting, lack of scum hunting, and fake dissonance are all anti-town, but that wasn't even part of your original reason to begin with. I've also taken the time to actually let you prove to me that you might actually be town here by outright interacting with you all of which have been met by dodging and outright avoidance. so.

and you didn't dodge interaction with just me, you had done it with nacho as well

actually, the second could be an addition to the first accusation, though the policy lynch thing and the summary given don't match up with your arguments against us at all

you still called our lynch a policy lynch which is different from calling it a scum lynch

Pedit: uh... I can quote out the dodging you did with nacho, because it happeend while I was sitting at Mcdonanlds waiting for my shift to start

SHroom: Chaos would be the bert talking to me in thread thing and what caused Jake to make the threat to replace out

ffery: when is it not to early to lynch scum?

I also think now would be a good time to hear those reasons.

Regardless of if i am right or wrong, stating my reason to you being town will have you dead tonight, which is decidedly a bad thing.

You dont care about the potential to be outted?

I probably won't get to it til tomorrow or the next day but so I can find it easier.

1. Hk, link me to where I supposedly dodged anyone cause that's false

2. HS , what questions did u ask me ? I don't remember seeing them.

Pages 4-9. you still havnt answered nachos question, and instead of answering mine, all you did was offer a counter question, then backed away when I had answered it.

VOTE: Jake

Well this dancing around the bush has already painted quite a target on my back so you might as well provide some evidence you aren't scum.
VOTE: HKC

If every post Ive made, and how ive treated my reads isnt sufficent proof of our alignment, nothing we do after isnt going to be, either.

But they aren't laying out a thought process and in fact they are outright refusing to do so.

If they want to actually outline their reasons for shit, I'm find with that but that's not what they have done.

Berts been pretty transparent in this field, and he hasnt been shy of sharing what ive told him outside this thread

And my interaction with you has been the closest I've ever gotten to outlining my early game thoughts, so while I have refused to explain one of my reads, making it a blanket statement to explain our behavior throughout the game isn't accurate.

and thus a lie

why can we not just kill jake

appeal to fear when you only had two votes on you?

fferycho is now a solid town read. And I'm starting to lean town on HS too.

unvote

I'm a little surprised you're solidly townreading us but yay. Agree on highshroomish.

I have independent reasons for thinking that both Jake and Aegor look scummy, but I'm having a little trouble picturing them as part of a team. :/

SMP is becoming a pretty distinct concern.

catboi's paraphrased fuckit-i'll-post-tomorrow gave me some town flickers, though!

Agreed on catboi. what do you think of my reasons for town-aegor?

uhh... yeah, it kinda is

and while you're practically begging for our lynch, your vote is on a lurker who is alot safer to be on when we already have one person voting us

.....

Appeal to fear is not you being afraid, it's you trying to get the people afraid to actually try and lynch you

that.... completely supports my argument

An appeal to fear (also called argumentum ad metum or argumentum in terrorem) is a fallacy in which a person attempts to create support for an idea by using deception and propaganda in attempts to increase fear and prejudice toward a competitor. The appeal to fear is common in marketing and politics.[1]

Examples

"If you continue to drink, you will die early as your father did."

makes the person scared of dying an early death

"If you cannot graduate from high school, you will live in poverty for the rest of your life."

makes the person scared of dying in poverty

"Voting for him is the same as voting for the terrorists."

makes general scared of voting X for president

"If you tell a lie, then no one will ever believe what you say again."

makes the kid scared of ever telling lies

"If we don't go to war, our country will be destroyed."

makes people scared of losing their country, thus causes them to go to war

go ahead and lynch me guys I really don't give a shit anymore but please please PLEASE lynch HK when I flip town.

an Attempt to either scare me out of voting you, or scaring town into thinking you might actually be town

if you want I will even throw out my role claim now so you can all chat about how it's a "bullshit" claim.

an attempt to scare people from voting you via making them think you're a PR....

In none of those scenarios, none of the people who are actually saying the words are scared so uhh...

UNVOTE:

I need a day or two to think

Nacho, when you get around, I'd like

your

opinion on the last couple pages

that's a little harsh, though could explain why I'm such an enticing target for scum

but, I don't see anything wrong with my post

lol, I didn't do anything. you just walked right into it

both messages are made to instil some kind of fear... which is an appeal to fear. I know my AtE and variants of.

I CLAIMED OWNERSHIP, NOW WHAT

VOTE: Jake

I'm done second guessing this

And, if I had a nickel for every moment you've said something similar Re me, id probably be pretty rich.

Im not a terrible player, but most people have a hard time figuring out why I say when and often do not agree with me. even among those who've I've played with multiple times, and among those with similar playstyles

You guys should if lynched me when you had your chance. You pissed off the bull and he's dropping logic like you never seen before.

Don't fucking lie to the guy who has a personal vendetta against liars

hahaha, unleashing the bull on some weakling?

I'm the APEX PREDATOR and I don't even do that shit (except for when I'm scum, maybe) and Shroom has actually pretty much spoken my mind so...

and, I've read through that game. I see lurky tendencies. Having more posts doesn't mean he isn't

and.... I see aboslutely no content in that second link, more post yeah, but content? I see some questions disguised as content but, no actual content.

and he's defintely not a newb as cabd has marked him as moderate so, even if he was scum he should have enough experience to know how to emulate his town game.

Jake seems like legitimately frustrated town here. I could see noob-scum panic claiming with just a few votes on them, but Jake isn't a noob.

except, I don't think he's panic claiming... not really, and even if he was even the most experienced are prone to such a thing. I still think he's trying to get people scared of lynching him.

HKC is not a strong town read, but it's not a case of whether you mind them or not - but I assume you're talking about finding Mara town and not Bert? To put it bluntly - Bert is Bert. He's a bit of a troll but a solid asset if town. But as scum (I might be wrong here because I'm going off something I read a while back from someone) I'm almost sure he's more manipulative. If I'm wrong, anyone can feel free to correct me. But that manipulation is something I'm not seeing in this game, and the blatant dissonance is bound to attract some attention. I don't think it's coming from a scum hydra.

fun fact, the hydra diss isn't even actually a thing. It's bert being a troll. The only dissonance we've had all game was our opinions on whatshisface

Scar

It'll be ur fault if our dissonance is our downfall

and this is actually in reference to the three votes I had made, and some behind the scenes shit. nothing that's happened in thread

Jake seems like legitimately frustrated town here. I could see noob-scum panic claiming with just a few votes on them, but Jake isn't a noob.

except, I don't think he's panic claiming... not really, and even if he was even the most experienced are prone to such a thing. I still think he's trying to get people scared of lynching him.

Fun fact I hate playing mafia but I'm pretty good at it and I would never, NEVER panic claim as scum. Even when the deck is stacked against me I don't give up.

As town I don't care as much cause i know we still out number mafia but when I'm mafia I don't trust my teammates to handle the game cause I'm conceited like that.

So you want to sit there and honestly think you got me to panic claim as scum with 2 fucking votes you are delusional. But do everyone on this site a favor. Cut the fucking trolling out if you are town.

well, I guess we are of kin there, I guess (though, whether or not I trust my scummates is dependent on my thoughts of their skills) though I did say I din't think you were panic claiming

and, believe it or not, this head isn't trolling and is playing seriously regardless of not knowing of this game existence to begin with

besides, if you were town, you wouldn't even be upset with us in the first place because, in your mind we are playing to our win-con

I've stated that I think you're fear mongering

appealing to fear

using scare tactics

trying to make people scared of you

I do not think that you, yourself is scared. I think you are trying to scare other people.

I've stated that at least twice, and you are twisting it into me saying I think you are scared when I'm not, why?

appealing to fear

using scare tactics

trying to make people scared of you

I do not think that you, yourself is scared. I think you are trying to scare other people.

I'm not doing that though. You are misinterpreting my actions. I'm actually telling people to lynch me.

@kdub - I didn't start changing my play style for this game. I started a while ago and have at least 2 completed games with it. It's more of a " go with the flow" playstyle. That kinda went out the window though when people started making up lies about me and calling things scummy that aren't scummy. Plus I got baited by hk's trolling.

oh, so you do know other phrases outside YOU'RE LYING.... that's good to know

Oh, and Ferycho is town-reading us because I'm pulling my town strings and instructing bert how to do so behind the scenes~~~

I'll make things easy on you, these are my posts, choose one.

[sangres]

We really should be lynching hkc/smp/shroom guaranteed 2 scum in this pool

and your reasons for thinking smp and shroom could be part of a team are?

[Jake from State Farm]

We really should be lynching hkc/smp/shroom guaranteed 2 scum in this pool

and your reasons for thinking smp and shroom could be part of a team are?

He was trying to pressure him early on to appear to be distancing but once he got a couple of votes he lied about his activity on another site to defend him. That stands out to me.

If smp is actually scum though I think your actions around the smp suspicion look off. Being you like to use meta yet you ignore the rock solid meta case I made.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

I don't think Aegor and Jake are scum together, though

Pedit: rock solid? lol

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

and I do still feel like his play is similar to mine in perpetual mylo

[Jake from State Farm]

Yes rock solid. He's not playing like ANY of his town games and instead is similar to the scum game I found. What's more rock solid then that?

It's certainly better than anything ANYONE else has come up with this game

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

mara has done a lot this game, so give her a break you guys

she has given like 155% and she didnt even want to be here

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

But he wasn't anywhere near being lynched. Would scum claim due to just a few votes to try to head things off at that point? There are strategic reasons for scum not locking themselves into a claim too early. I guess it's possible, but I can't recall any instances off the top of my head where that has happened.

I've done it, actually and in one of my better scum-games

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

i'm gonna insist you support both the HKC and the AD ones.

insisting?

[Mac]

God this game is sucking the life out of me.

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

make things easier on yourself and vote jake

[Jake from State Farm]

Or if you want to lynch scum vote smp

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

Or if you want to lynch scum, vote jakey.

you know you want to boys and girls

[Hello Kitty Creampuff]

that panicked claim was so scum this isnt even funny anymore. gawd.

[Mac]

Jake, do you have any townreads?

[Jake from State Farm]

make things easier on yourself and vote jake

Lynching me will make this have easier to follow I will concede that.

As long as I'm alive I'll push on my scum reads since nobody has made a compelling case on an alternative.

I mean you want me lynched but you haven't even made a compelling argument or provided 1 reason that wasn't a lie or twisting of the truth

P.edit - i have 1, the person I think is the ??? Voter.