Town for sure:
Policy Lynch
LynxKuroneko
Ghatokaca
Probably town:
Catastrophe
Brantz
Tiershift
Meh town:
Krystal Bald
Kthxbye
Copper223
Lean scum (because of dumping a vote and then disappearing):
Faster than Light
Scum for sure:
Cask of Amontillado
Medea the Alien
One reason for copper sliding down my list I can't talk about. The other reason is that he HAS been conciliatory and sort of wishy-washy about CoA while at the same time snapping at Tiershift. Something seems off there.
As for a case on CoA:
He attacks Krystal and threatens them for supposedly faking a post restriction. Apparently both heads are in agreement about this being faked and TTH thinks it means Krystal is scum.
Attacks copper, then distances from that in
Post 96 by claiming they were drunk when they posted it.
Sniping at copper for a while about Krystal's post restriction and Lynx. The arguments about Krystal AND Lynx felt really forced (see
Post 97,
Post 100 -
Post 101 until
Post 106 and
Post 108 when CoA reiterates their suspicion of Krystal. There's never an explanation of why faking a post restriction in a highly flavoured game is alignment indicative, but that's mainly what they chose to focus on.
In
Post 233 we discover that CoA has a mild townread on Krystal despite the fact that he says two paragraphs earlier: "I don't know you well enough to decide whether you'd do something so horrifically anti-town just to make your role more interesting, and better safe than sorry." He says nothing about Lynx in that post.
This speaks for itself, since Lynx was essentially asking to be lynched and asking us to trust him to use his role correctly:
↑ CaskOfAmontillado wrote:My problem with Boo is exactly the same as why copper's townreading her, minus the meta. Town should be looking at the Lynx claim and saying 'But wouldn't it be better to lynch scum?' Scum are the ones who should be thinking 'That forwards my win condition!' and withholding the vote is a great way to look helpful without actually being such.
I can't help feeling that no matter what I had done, CoA would have found a way to interpret it as scummy. I read it the same way as the sniping at copper. I don't know what that means, though. The conciliatory comment is really bothering me. I thought that copper was town because I thought that CoA was scum; I'm not so sure now.
And yeah, I could go on and on about
Post 281 (she talks about and to Lynx too much and she doesn't have fully developed reads on day one) and
Post 283 she didn't vote town soon enough. CoA criticises me for not giving refined reads at a time when he'd barely given any at all. And then look at
Post 564 for a delightful contrast. Gee, those aren't skeletal reads at all.
I felt that CoA wasn't really paying attention to Lynx at first and trying to figure out what was going on. CoA's attacks on me for deciding to trust Lynx and waiting to vote until I had better reads on people overall is also pinging my scumdar -- if I'd voted as soon as I decided Lynx was town and should be allowed to use his role the way he wanted, that would have been the excuse for CoA.
And ninja'd: I am sorry if you felt I was rude. I think your comment about conciliatory being a towntell is funny. I think your whole behaviour around copper is weird and has been getting weirder as the game progresses. It does not fit with the facts I think I have.
"Oh, you can't help that," said the Cat: "we're all mad here. I'm mad. You're mad."
"How do you know I'm mad?" said Alice.
"You must be," said the Cat, "or you wouldn't have come here."
