A Musical Mafia! (Game over)

[Mirhawk]

Er, were we talking about seniors? I was referring to Piper in 4944.

lol

[True Ogre]

The butthurt is tie up in my read as far as that goes, btw

[True Ogre]

Er, were we talking about seniors? I was referring to Piper in 4944.

lol

Okay, but I asked at the very start when I voted Seniors and you decided to vote Piper why you wouldn't just sheep me.
I want to know what this aversion to a Seniors lynch is.

[Mirhawk]

lol ok, I'd like an explanation on that too. What do you think they were butthurt about?

[True Ogre]

It was the crumbing/soft-claiming in the first place, plus the (butthurt although i've been told not to say that in previous games) followed by the "reveal" which is worrying.

I'm not sure I follow. What do you mean by this?

Not the butthurt which is funny and only offensive to someone who is wound up way to tight, but rather the other two parts.

Um so they said they had some kind of infomation, then failed to follow through, and then when pressed they got uptight and started blaming everyone else for pushing them, and then revealed.. some stuff.
Those actions were spread across both heads though. I'm irritated but still at a loss as to why it would be scum (or town). It was just really weird behaviour.

[True Ogre]

lol ok, I'd like an explanation on that too. What do you think they were butthurt about?

Why won't you lynch Seniors?

[Mirhawk]

I feel somewhat like seniors has suffered a lot under pretty terrible scum cases all game. I still don't see much against them other then the equivalent of "I don't like their attitude", or meta related stuff.

I mean, what is the current case for Seniors being scum? I don't even know. It isn't the opportunism, as that's recent and nobody's paying a great deal of attention to it. There's been literally so much bickering on their wagon that I have no idea what anyone's scumreading them for. I'm moderately sure it's not for things I personally find scummy, but beyond that I don't know.

[True Ogre]

That's a good theory for Seniors being town if the option wasn't you die or Seniors dies? I mean you know you're town?

Piper's today's lynch then?

[True Ogre]

I'm just wondering where your awareness is.

[True Ogre]

UNVOTE: Seniors
VOTE: Mirhawk

[Mirhawk]

I just don't really think they're very scummy and I can't think of any benefit we'd gain from flipping them. Well aside from not having to listen to them arguing with piper anymore, But if that's the gain on the table I would much rather take it off the Piper end.

Maybe I should be voting them, but I'm just not into it.

[Mirhawk]

lol

[Mirhawk]

I'm irritated but still at a loss as to why it would be scum (or town). It was just really weird behaviour.

That's mostly how I feel about the beginning bits. I feel that how they acted after I started pushing them was pretty scummy too. Not when I first started asking them questions, but later.

[True Ogre]

Well this is really weird for me because I don't know why you'd elect to have yourself lynched instead of someone whose alignment you don't actually know.

[Mirhawk]

Why are you so sure Seniors is scum?

[Mirhawk]

You're saying I should sheep you onto seniors but aren't giving me any reason to aside from something that only benefits me.

[Mirhawk]

I'm almost certain your town, it's not like I think your going to lie to me.

Alternatively, is there a reason you don't want to vote for Piper? You know exactly what my stance is on them, where's the flaw in my logic?

[True Ogre]

Does your role PM say "Town xxx"?
Does Seniors'?

I mean I know you probably have principles but are you flat out just saying that your own role PM is is less likely to be town than the claimed wig vendors'?

I mean I sort of get it?

[True Ogre]

You *haven't given any logic* as to why Piper is scum
You keep saying things don't make sense as town
But things need to have a rationale for them as scum, to be scum-motivated

[True Ogre]

I just voted Seniors
Sorry but I need to fuck off right now
And will bbl

Sorry if you're town but I'm just not seeing town actions happening as soon as you got pressured

<3

[Mirhawk]

I don't like compromising my reads for personal gain, it's almost certainty due to pride.

I know it's hypocritical for me to be annoyed at other players for being unwilling to look outside their own reads while doing it myself. But hey, who's perfect.

[Mirhawk]

My logic is town players don't make antitown choices for no reason. I've seen nothing to convince me that this is not true.

Granted the scum rationale for this isn't super strong, but there's practically none for town.

Anyways, good rap, was fun, would do again.

[Dwlee99]

Mirhawk came out lookinf town in that back and forth imo. what changed your mind, ogre?

[talah]

I have half a dozen black holes about why he'd play like he is as town.

If you were being lynched would you throw your life on the line for Seniors?

[Dwlee99]

I wouldnt lynch myself over them but I also wouldnt WANT to lynch my town read