Mafiascum.net

In post 323, magenta_thegreat wrote:because I did.

Where?

In post 323, magenta_thegreat wrote:he had made himself obv town pretty early to those that know how he plays (Imo),

He made himself obvtown pretty early yet you're getting paranoid on him?

orcinus, why did you ask me my read on ffery before attacking her?

mara, why are you trusting orc's read on ffery over mine?

In post 316, phokdapolees wrote:Just got back on, and now there's over 300 posts... I'll catch up and post my thoughts.

This game might be really fucking confusing.
Sorry about that!

In post 146, magenta_thegreat wrote:

In post 142, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 81, magenta_thegreat wrote:

In post 52, Nachomamma8 wrote:I think Magenta is scum
I'm getting too many townreads.

NOT AGAIN.

PLEASE.

In retrospect, I don't like this. Turning me attacking orcinus into me always attacking orcinus (especially when I'm not attacking him directly but instead indirectly through the towniness of others) seems strange. At first I thought it was coming from Mara :/

Pfft, you won't get a reaction anywhere near that

and, I'm not going to get trolled by scum this game.

In post 137, magenta_thegreat wrote:you don't count the last couple games, sure. I can read him just fine, and probably better than anyone else.

Probably. Hence you scumreading him is not such a good thing because I am decently confident in my ability to read him, especially earlygame. He seems pretty town here.

and I am still decently confident in my ability to read him, it'll just take a little longer than usual. His play so far has been null, I can easily see the town side but I can just as easily see the scum-side of the play, and I can see TIP easily emulating his town play

In post 137, magenta_thegreat wrote:maybe Ffery, though her scum-play is better in Hydra IIRC, and she sure as hell has gotten better at unifying her two different games (I blame C) so you would be the most ideal Veto,

Setting up for Ffery paranoia?

Maybe?

you know you aren't going to get me to break with weak stuff like this. push a little harder

In post 137, magenta_thegreat wrote:and speaking of becoming Obv town, I'm not seeing it yet. what's taking so long tammy?

What's taking so long...? It's page 7, Mara.
Or 8 or whatever.

Point?

the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

TIP did make himself Obv town early on, but he isn't keeping up on his appearances, so yes. I'm getting paranoid of him.

I'm trusting Orci over you because he is an Unbiased opinion I know I can trust without fear of having to be back-stabbed

I wasn't expecting that to happen.





Initially I read Irish's opening posts as town (like this and this) However, I really dislike his attempt to paint the Nacho/Mara interaction (which I'm going to purposely not out my read on) as scum. I also dislike the fact that he seemed to lack any actual focus on the situation but he still reached the conclusion based off of a few pages of back and forth. I do not know how Irish plays, so it's possible I'm mixing up an erratic playstyle with what I consider scumtells usually but right now I'd actually be happy to join in on a wagon on him.

, why do you think Nacho/Mara is scum vs scum?



I have a couple of mild towntells I'm going to refrain from outing completely given the early nature of this game but I'll tell you that Sound of Silence is probably town. I feel completely out of the loop to be honest but I guess I prefer this over a snail pace.

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

Why?

Oh, and one more thing - Mastin's idea is absolutely, terrifyingly bad but I won't get into that now either. Just don't do it.

projectmatt townread firmed up a bit.

In post 320, magenta_thegreat wrote:well no, considering I am still recovering from my town-reading scum-you in every game you were scum. I havn't figured out the difference between town-ffery and scum-ffery other than what Nacho told me Re your interactions with your buddies and, when I try to use meta I end up being burned

I think my scumplay wound up in some sort of blind spot of yours, because IMO it's still significantly different from my town play despite considerable effort.

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

It seriously missed the mark.

In post 333, Nachomamma8 wrote:projectmatt townread firmed up a bit.

That's not an answer.

In post 336, projectmatt wrote:

In post 333, Nachomamma8 wrote:projectmatt townread firmed up a bit.

That's not an answer.

firmed up a bit more
(i'm working on it)

In post 31, phokdapolees wrote:Anyway, mastin, what is the point of your fake townbloc, and how did you choose the members?

I liked this. Straight, to the point, solid questioning.
No posturing, just pure and free questioning.

In post 35, phokdapolees wrote:(I'm also nacho's newbie ) What is far from 100%? You didn't even give a reason for voting for me besides saying that you thought TIP was town.

I liked this too. He's interrogating an old IC a bit, and the tone in his response is good.

In post 43, phokdapolees wrote:

Sound of Silence wrote:So whatdayya think?
Is he town for it? Is he scum for it? Or is he just downright trolling you?

It's hard to tell when he hasn't even given an actual reason for his vote yet. He says that he wants to discuss it, but he's not giving anything to discuss. It seems slightly scummy at this point, like he's just trying to seem town by saying "hey, let's discuss my vote," without giving anything to work with, but I still want him to state his reasoning.

He seems frustrated that he doesn't understand mastin's vote.
He doesn't seem frustrated with mastin voting him specifically.

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:but he isn't keeping up on his appearances, so yes.

Where has he failed to keep up his appearances?

In post 335, Sound of Silence wrote:

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

It seriously missed the mark.

Oh wait...you mean send Nacho into a rage? So many f's in that sentence I thought it was addressed to me.

Re: 324
Hide*
-correction by GIF-

Okay, good enough.

In post 340, Sound of Silence wrote:

In post 335, Sound of Silence wrote:

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

It seriously missed the mark.

Oh wait...you mean send Nacho into a rage? So many f's in that sentence I thought it was addressed to me.

It still missed the mark if that was its intention.
I doubt that was its intention though. Mara is claiming that all her weirdness was planned the whole time and is behind the scenes town reaction testing, and I just don't believe that.

In post 146, magenta_thegreat wrote:and, I'm not going to get trolled by scum this game.

In post 146, magenta_thegreat wrote:you know you aren't going to get me to break with weak stuff like this. push a little harder

"I'm not gonna get trolled by you this game nacho"
"i'm gonna troll you nacho"
Seems inconsistent.

It isn't to far off of your push on bert/ns, just a little bit more elaborate. what's so incredulous about it being a reaction test, considering I have done it before?

also, every TIP post after our 1v1 doesn't really jive

and to this degree

In post 343, Nachomamma8 wrote:

In post 340, Sound of Silence wrote:

In post 335, Sound of Silence wrote:

In post 329, magenta_thegreat wrote:the bolded was supposed to send you into a fiery rage of fury

It seriously missed the mark.

Oh wait...you mean send Nacho into a rage? So many f's in that sentence I thought it was addressed to me.

It still missed the mark if that was its intention.
I doubt that was its intention though. Mara is claiming that all her weirdness was planned the whole time and is behind the scenes town reaction testing, and I just don't believe that.

and it was a taunt. what else was it supposed to do?

In post 38, Sound of Silence wrote:What makes you think he isn't town?

There are other things, but mainly? Playing the newb card. Read his games. In every town game, he doesn't play it. In most of his scum games, he does. There's also the content and tone. Phok displays a greater amount of confidence and logical thinking as scum, whereas when town, is more doubtful and unassured of himself.

In post 45, Nachomamma8 wrote:i will not mislynch projectmatt

Serious, legitimate, townread here. Because I had the exact same impulse, here. (That being, projectmatt's opener was scummy, but ultimately town.)

In post 56, Tammy wrote:But that is exactly what you tried to do by making a pre-formed town bloc...halt the normal scumhunting procedure.

The idea was to channel the normal scumhunting onto four players for a time period of a week. Then, from there, normal scumhunt everyone. However, if the idea was rejected, I'd rather not have us be debating it for ten pages, because that'd be a waste of time and effort. (And I am hoping the 11 extra pages aren't discussing it. ) Sure, yeah, question my alignment for proposing the idea, but not the idea itself. Which is either something we should do or shouldn't do.

I still stick by my answer of us doing it, considering my serious townreads on SoS and Nacho mean half the members I want in there already are town.

Anyway, this post is for the first three pages.

am i the only one who gets really irrationally frustrated by mastin's posts?