No. We are not doing this, Nancy. Do not comment on every single post unless you're scumhunting. We do not need general comments that contribute nothing to the game state.
In post 1165, Lie Ren wrote:I honestly think Trojan actually has been putting in some serious work, I have a solid townread on them now
Can I get some details here?
I'm also interested in this. I'm clearly not taking this game super seriously... I am doing some amount of solving though but I'm curious to hear about what you mean by "serious work".
When I say "serious work", I don't mean actual game solving effort. I just liked the direction they were going and how they were interacting with me. Essentially they shaped up.
I would still like some specifics. I'm wondering how you came to this conclusion based on what they posted between A and B, and also whether you can convince me they're not scum.
In post 1142, Trojan Horses wrote:Mastina isn’t an easy read but she seems to be pretty genuine here, where she seems kind of off as scum.
Oh that's a really good way of describing it yeah.
As scum I've tried a lifetime to not feel "off" to myself but to this day, never had a scumgame where I didn't feel 'off'. And when I can tell I am 'off' as scum, I can tell that others can tell, too.
Similarly so for as town. Like this game, I can recognize I'm not the normal town mastina but can still feel that I'm *a* town mastina and am not 'off' to a degree where scumreads on me should exist. They shouldn't.
This is also a mastina scumpost. I believe I recall some game where she went on and on about excuses why she didn't match up to her normal self but was totally town, possibly in the absence of anyone pressing her on it.
Mastina talks about her meta all the time, this is NIA for her, she is tonally town. I have never seen her effectively fake that in any game where I’ve played with scum!her.
In post 1171, Trojan Horses wrote:I was tl you before I knew that but that read is strengthened by knowing this.
~N
oh, nancy drew is in trojan horses? they might actually be scum, then.
Why? and nope.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 5:35 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 1450, northsidegal wrote:there is also the fact that it's not exactly clear that your last line has "even if i am lying" implicit in it. i think that a reading of your post in which you take it that the author believes what they are saying still has the inconsistency which i brought up.
it feels like overjustification, especially given that i've never said that it's because of her not posting that her presence scum-inclines your slot. like, "she can't post, but even if she could i'd be making her post if we were scum, so either way you're wrong". like, just mentioning that she can't post seems like justification enough to me. a plausible thought explaining the last line to me went something like "oh no, ND lurking is getting us scumread as i knew would happen, need to deny it on multiple fronts" or something like that. that's a bit exaggerated but i'm not sure of a better way to word the thought i had.
FYI, nsg I’m literally grueving a dead friend and haven’t been on MS aq regularily. Check it out, if you think I’m bsinf you.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 5:37 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 1451, Trojan Horses wrote:Okay, then. Well, I will say that she initially wasn't very fond of my deciding to troll around, but she does find it amusing.
I'll list off some reads of her from Discord:
Molla probably town as his progression on NSG looks genuine, although he's not an easy read.
Gamma probably town.
Elmo seemed scummy.
And pointed out a towntell for RC.
Still think this. Gamma looks like he’s genuinely sorting and molla sounds super townie.
In post 1423, BBmolla wrote:Why are people so dead this game what the actual fuck
too many dead people to be fucking scum
THIS IS HOW WE LOSE BROS
CAN WE PLEASE NOT LET THIS GAME DIE
Lol this is the fakest shit of all time, this is prime 2008 era shitty scumplay
But what about his nsg progression? Do you not tr that?
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 5:40 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 1457, Not_Mafia wrote:Will hammer Molla when he hits L-1, not reading anything but VCs until that happens, will be back to shitpost as the mood takes me
Why? Are you basing this solely on one post? I don’t think molla fakes that progression on nsg, so no.
In post 1451, Trojan Horses wrote:Okay, then. Well, I will say that she initially wasn't very fond of my deciding to troll around, but she does find it amusing.
I'll list off some reads of her from Discord:
Molla probably town as his progression on NSG looks genuine, although he's not an easy read.
Gamma probably town.
Elmo seemed scummy.
And pointed out a towntell for RC
.
Please enlighten the rest of the class
Town!RC cares a lot about not mislynching and tends to hard defend easy mislynchbait like lhfs. I’ve seen him do that in both DnD and in CoaLITion.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 5:53 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 1525, gobbledygook wrote:No. We are not doing this, Nancy. Do not comment on every single post unless you're scumhunting. We do not need general comments that contribute nothing to the game state.
I am. I’m trying to get caught up so sue me.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 6:05 pm
by Trojan Horses
I jus think it’s really funny that Gobbles townlocked me as scum in Coalition and both wrongly sr me in Radja’s and this game.
In post 1165, Lie Ren wrote:I honestly think Trojan actually has been putting in some serious work, I have a solid townread on them now
Can I get some details here?
I'm also interested in this. I'm clearly not taking this game super seriously... I am doing some amount of solving though but I'm curious to hear about what you mean by "serious work".
When I say "serious work", I don't mean actual game solving effort. I just liked the direction they were going and how they were interacting with me. Essentially they shaped up.
I would still like some specifics. I'm wondering how you came to this conclusion based on what they posted between A and B, and also whether you can convince me they're not scum.
In post 1142, Trojan Horses wrote:Mastina isn’t an easy read but she seems to be pretty genuine here, where she seems kind of off as scum.
Oh that's a really good way of describing it yeah.
As scum I've tried a lifetime to not feel "off" to myself but to this day, never had a scumgame where I didn't feel 'off'. And when I can tell I am 'off' as scum, I can tell that others can tell, too.
Similarly so for as town. Like this game, I can recognize I'm not the normal town mastina but can still feel that I'm *a* town mastina and am not 'off' to a degree where scumreads on me should exist. They shouldn't.
This is also a mastina scumpost. I believe I recall some game where she went on and on about excuses why she didn't match up to her normal self but was totally town, possibly in the absence of anyone pressing her on it.
Mastina talks about her meta all the time, this is NIA for her, she is tonally town. I have never seen her effectively fake that in any game where I’ve played with scum!her.
I know she talks about her meta all the time. That's not what I was concerned with.
You'll have to forgive me if I can't grok ~~tone~~~~~.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 6:28 pm
by northsidegal
In post 1480, jjh927 wrote:I'm kinda interested in why NSG seems to lack confidence in her read on me atm
my current inclination is to scumread you. are you more confused that i lack confidence than that i scumread you? i guess i'll just ask: how do you think i should be reading you?
In post 1450, northsidegal wrote:there is also the fact that it's not exactly clear that your last line has "even if i am lying" implicit in it. i think that a reading of your post in which you take it that the author believes what they are saying still has the inconsistency which i brought up.
it feels like overjustification, especially given that i've never said that it's because of her not posting that her presence scum-inclines your slot. like, "she can't post, but even if she could i'd be making her post if we were scum, so either way you're wrong". like, just mentioning that she can't post seems like justification enough to me. a plausible thought explaining the last line to me went something like "oh no, ND lurking is getting us scumread as i knew would happen, need to deny it on multiple fronts" or something like that. that's a bit exaggerated but i'm not sure of a better way to word the thought i had.
FYI, nsg I’m literally grueving a dead friend and haven’t been on MS aq regularily. Check it out, if you think I’m bsinf you.
i've never once indicated that i scumread you because of a lack of posts nor have i indicated that i think that you could be lying about not being able to post. i'm sorry to hear about your friend.
In post 1165, Lie Ren wrote:I honestly think Trojan actually has been putting in some serious work, I have a solid townread on them now
Can I get some details here?
I'm also interested in this. I'm clearly not taking this game super seriously... I am doing some amount of solving though but I'm curious to hear about what you mean by "serious work".
When I say "serious work", I don't mean actual game solving effort. I just liked the direction they were going and how they were interacting with me. Essentially they shaped up.
I would still like some specifics. I'm wondering how you came to this conclusion based on what they posted between A and B, and also whether you can convince me they're not scum.
In post 1142, Trojan Horses wrote:Mastina isn’t an easy read but she seems to be pretty genuine here, where she seems kind of off as scum.
Oh that's a really good way of describing it yeah.
As scum I've tried a lifetime to not feel "off" to myself but to this day, never had a scumgame where I didn't feel 'off'. And when I can tell I am 'off' as scum, I can tell that others can tell, too.
Similarly so for as town. Like this game, I can recognize I'm not the normal town mastina but can still feel that I'm *a* town mastina and am not 'off' to a degree where scumreads on me should exist. They shouldn't.
This is also a mastina scumpost. I believe I recall some game where she went on and on about excuses why she didn't match up to her normal self but was totally town, possibly in the absence of anyone pressing her on it.
Mastina talks about her meta all the time, this is NIA for her, she is tonally town. I have never seen her effectively fake that in any game where I’ve played with scum!her.
I know she talks about her meta all the time. That's not what I was concerned with.
You'll have to forgive me if I can't grok ~~tone~~~~~.
It takes awhile and not every player can be read off tone but as good as she is, she hasn’t been able to fake the sincerity and genuineness of her town games, especially when it’s as obvious as it is here. In RC uPick, I don’t ever recall her ever making reads the same way she is here. Scum!Mastina almost seems robotic. The passion she expressed while making her tr, especially on Gobbles and Cakes, isn’t something I’ve seen her do as scum.
In post 1450, northsidegal wrote:there is also the fact that it's not exactly clear that your last line has "even if i am lying" implicit in it. i think that a reading of your post in which you take it that the author believes what they are saying still has the inconsistency which i brought up.
it feels like overjustification, especially given that i've never said that it's because of her not posting that her presence scum-inclines your slot. like, "she can't post, but even if she could i'd be making her post if we were scum, so either way you're wrong". like, just mentioning that she can't post seems like justification enough to me. a plausible thought explaining the last line to me went something like "oh no, ND lurking is getting us scumread as i knew would happen, need to deny it on multiple fronts" or something like that. that's a bit exaggerated but i'm not sure of a better way to word the thought i had.
FYI, nsg I’m literally grueving a dead friend and haven’t been on MS aq regularily. Check it out, if you think I’m bsinf you.
i've never once indicated that i scumread you because of a lack of posts nor have i indicated that i think that you could be lying about not being able to post. i'm sorry to hear about your friend.
Thank you, it’s been really hard. What is your reasoning then? I really don’t understand it.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 6:39 pm
by Trojan Horses
In post 1541, Trojan Horses wrote:Thank you, it’s been really hard. What is your reasoning then? I really don’t understand it.
Nancy I can answer most of your Qs on Discord. I think the hyperpost catchup style makes the game generally harder to read!
In post 1450, northsidegal wrote:there is also the fact that it's not exactly clear that your last line has "even if i am lying" implicit in it. i think that a reading of your post in which you take it that the author believes what they are saying still has the inconsistency which i brought up.
it feels like overjustification, especially given that i've never said that it's because of her not posting that her presence scum-inclines your slot. like, "she can't post, but even if she could i'd be making her post if we were scum, so either way you're wrong". like, just mentioning that she can't post seems like justification enough to me. a plausible thought explaining the last line to me went something like "oh no, ND lurking is getting us scumread as i knew would happen, need to deny it on multiple fronts" or something like that. that's a bit exaggerated but i'm not sure of a better way to word the thought i had.
FYI, nsg I’m literally grueving a dead friend and haven’t been on MS aq regularily. Check it out, if you think I’m bsinf you.
Omg that's terrible...hopefully not Corona virus related?
In post 1450, northsidegal wrote:there is also the fact that it's not exactly clear that your last line has "even if i am lying" implicit in it. i think that a reading of your post in which you take it that the author believes what they are saying still has the inconsistency which i brought up.
it feels like overjustification, especially given that i've never said that it's because of her not posting that her presence scum-inclines your slot. like, "she can't post, but even if she could i'd be making her post if we were scum, so either way you're wrong". like, just mentioning that she can't post seems like justification enough to me. a plausible thought explaining the last line to me went something like "oh no, ND lurking is getting us scumread as i knew would happen, need to deny it on multiple fronts" or something like that. that's a bit exaggerated but i'm not sure of a better way to word the thought i had.
FYI, nsg I’m literally grueving a dead friend and haven’t been on MS aq regularily. Check it out, if you think I’m bsinf you.
Omg that's terrible...hopefully not Corona virus related?
No, sudden unexpected death due to liver complications resulting from an auto-immune disease. Thanks.
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 7:23 pm
by Trojan Horses
I townread SirCakez now.
-Stuxnet
Posted: Sun Apr 12, 2020 7:44 pm
by BBmolla
jj's most recent posts are kind of weird and I don't know what to make of them
