Calvin and Hobbes Mafia(GAME OVER! Grownups Mafia Wins!)

[Mr E Roll]

penguin_aliens aren't they scum from the planet Zog? Yes, I think they are.

VOTE: penguin_alien

[Mr E Roll]

Yeah that's what I thought

VOTE: tso

I did that too.

And now you did it twice.

Why do people get naked? To take baths.
Why do people need baths? Because they are scummy.

Twice the naked-vote scum tell is twice as scummy.

Unvote

VOTE: TiphaineDeath

[Mr E Roll]

errr...... @MR E. My first vote was random, and my second had reasoning.... Am I missing something?

Although you second vote post did contain some content besides the actual vote I didn’t see any explanation or reasoning for the vote itself.

Still I could see that maybe it isn’t a truly naked vote. Which makes me wonder why you would take a bath without getting naked? You must have something to hide. Who has something to hide… scum.

Unvote

I’ve had my RVS fun.

[Mr E Roll]

I'm thinking T S O and TD scumteam.

But you're not voting for either of them.

VOTE: TheIrishPope

[Mr E Roll]

So you think they are scum but you aren't voting for them? Why not?

[Mr E Roll]

You called them out as the scum team if you believed that how would voting for them be a silly nilly vote?

If you don't believe it why did you call them out?

[Mr E Roll]

It's a thought I put in the open because I am transparent. Hiding info is harmful to Town, don't you agree?

Considering only like 10 people have talked and we have 4 pages full of shitty votes, I have nothing
Also, given that I gave a thought about T S O and TD, I won't give reads any more

So now you have decided to intentionally be harmful to town?

That seems a sure fire way to convince us that our votes are misguided.

Feels like you are scum that has already given up and just don't want us to be able to establish your partners through interaction.

[Mr E Roll]

If you were town you would want to help town even as you were being lynched.

[Mr E Roll]

How am I supposed to sheep somebody who won't vote and won't provide reads?

[Mr E Roll]

there is no scum in this game, only calvin



boy i wonder what the scum role flavor is? those zog? that old teacher whose name I forgot? exciting !

What does this mean?

Isn’t scum… scum regardless of the flavor?

[Mr E Roll]

too much mafia too little calvin & hobbes

I going to pounce on this like Hobbes on a can of tuna.

Too little mafia and too little Calvin and Hobbes. Third post and really no attempt to develop any content.

There seems to be some incongruity between your supposed excitement to discover the scum flavor you expressed in 114 and the disappointment you’ve expressed in 117 about the lame flavor.

I’m also concerned about your lack of interest in scum. Flavor should be something that adds to the enjoyment not something that negates the importance of scum hunting.

Unvote

VOTE: Metal Sonic

we are lynching zoidberg today

vote: zoidberg

Why should we lynching zoidberg today?(If the answer is because he’s scum, follow up question; why is he scum?)

[Mr E Roll]

I'd disagree
Silly = scum
Stupid might be Town or scum

Trolololol syntax
Zoidberg, so your actions are Town motivated? Explain.

Why describe the difference between silly and stupid if you are going to use them interchangeably?

Why does the incongruity itself make him scum though?

The incongruity makes me believe he is lying. I think lying about an interest in discovering the flavor is more likely to come from scum.

In fact I think he told us what the scum flavor is.

there is no scum in this game, only calvin

Scum flavor is the bad/evil/mischievous side of Calvin.

[Mr E Roll]

Why describe the difference between silly and stupid if you are going to use them interchangeably?

Did you miss this question or choose to ignore it?

Zoidberg, it's incumbent upon you to show me you are Town. You haven't done anything Towny, and I don't see Town motivation from your posts.

If you believe town has the burden to prove their innocence what should I make of your decision to withhold your reads until some pressure was taken off of you? If definitely did not appear that you felt it was incumbent upon you to show yourself as town..

[Mr E Roll]

In fact I think he told us what the scum flavor is.

there is no scum in this game, only calvin

Scum flavor is the bad/evil/mischievous side of Calvin.

If Metal Sonic was Scum, why would he tell us this?

My theory is that his disappointment with the very bad and lame, flavor resulted in sub-optimal play.

If you think my premise is wrong what do you think he intended to convey by saying there is no scum only Calvin?

[Mr E Roll]

I'm thinking Zoidberg is scum for that stupid ass scumteam guess
But wagon ahoy, I recognise Metal Sonic as scummy, but he may be one of those useless players. I will lead the Zoidberg wagon.
VOTE: Zoidberg

So you voted for Zoidberg for doing something stupid which you’ve said could come from either town or scum over Metal Sonic who you have recognized as scummy.

Is it because joining the Metal Sonic wagon would have placed you in the butter zone?

[Mr E Roll]

So you think being silly is a stronger scum tell than be being scummy?

[Mr E Roll]

Knowing Metal Sonic, yes

I havent even played a game with you before

?????????????

unless you are an alt or hydra

What did Metal Sonic do between post 190 and 194 that warranted a vote change? Other than expose your lie.

Unvote

VOTE: TheIrishPope

[Mr E Roll]

E Roll have you ever played with MS?

Actually that question applies to everyone on the MS wagon? Have you played with him before?

No. And for clarification I left the MS wagon and am voting TIP

[Mr E Roll]

@NS: Usually, D1 is the longest. Why are you so anxious for it to end?

I don’t think this is so much an indication of anxiousness as a reminder that he plans to largely coast on day one.

[Mr E Roll]

Regarding TIP’s most recent/mistake lie, I’d like to remind people this is not the first time he has posted…. ahem… erroneous information this game.

Knowing Metal Sonic, yes

I havent even played a game with you before

?????????????

unless you are an alt or hydra

-----------------------------------------------------------------------------

[

@Psyche: I think that on its own, it wouldn't be bad, but the fact that he slipped and claimed three scum/multiball setup and then did the same with a daytime QT is pretty bad. Right now, it'd be a great flip, since if he flips scum, it confirms both of those things for town.

I’m going to get behind this reasoning because right now I don’t even know what I’m looking for. Those potential scum slips if validated would probably be the flip that gives us the most information.

Unvote

VOTE: Zoidberg

[Mr E Roll]

I don't want a hammer until Varsoon and rofl come back.

This post makes me thimk Zoidberg isn’t worried about Varsoon having incriminating information on him. Otherwise he would want rofl hammered before Varsoon could add anything to his case.

@Zoidberg but why do we need to wait for rofl to come back if you already have a guilty on him?

[Mr E Roll]

Irish if you knew Zoidberg fake claimed why didnt you track him?

[Mr E Roll]

If you thought there were duplicates why did you want to lynch him immediately?

[Mr E Roll]

Until I see some sound justification for the fake claim

VOTE: Zoidberg

[Mr E Roll]

You gambit like this in any past games zoidberg?

Nope. Always wanted to, though. At the end of the day the game's supposed to be about fun. Ultimately if I get lynched for this I won't feel too bad.

In my defense I planned to reveal the fakeclaim during twilight, but the thread got locked so fast I didn't have time.

Why didn’t you come clean first post of the day then? Why wait until a counter claim?

[Mr E Roll]

Wouldn't a claim of hider also have prevented scum from targeting him?

Invalidating his earlier claim of wanting to draw the Nk away from PR's.

rofl was so incredibly obvscum, but the wagon was slipping away from me. It's one of those situations that happens all too often where town was going to talk itself out of a good thing, and we weren't anywhere close to a MYLO/LYLO situation. I also wanted to draw the nightkill away from a power role if possible.

My plan was to claim hider so that any docs would stay away from me, but the thread was locked before I could submit that post.

Also, it was just really entertaining.

[Mr E Roll]

Rubicon is scum for, you know, lying

Why is Rubicon scum for lying?

Didn’t you say earlier that town can lie?

Varsoon, I suppose Town could do that as well

@TIP: Do what?

Be rude, lying, etc.
I'm town and scum? wat

Can you explain the difference between Rubicon's alleged lie and Zoidberg’s verified lie that leads you to believe one is town and one is scum?

Also explain again why you didn’t know that Zoidberg was fake claiming? You thought that there might be duplicate uses of the flavor name Tracer Bullet that would have different roles? Does that even make sense?